Click here to download

Access to Constitutional Remedies, Previous Exhaustion and "Subsidiary" Management of ECHR Structural Violations stemming from legislative defects.
Journal Title: DIRITTI UMANI E DIRITTO INTERNAZIONALE 
Author/s: Andrea Saccucci 
Year:  2012 Issue: Language: Italian 
Pages:  29 Pg. 263-291 FullText PDF:  331 KB
DOI:  10.3280/DUDI2012-002002
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:  clicca qui   and here 


The increasing number of judgments delivered by the Strasbourg Court in cases of human rights violations stemming from a systemic problem in the domestic legal system of a contracting State (so called "structural violations") and the development of the caselaw on the obligation of States to adopt general measures under Article 46 ECHR to remove the causes of such violations (including by amending the relevant legislation) are reinforcing the idea of Court as a sort of pan-European constitutional jurisdiction entrusted with the mandate to safeguard the European public order. At the same time, the "collective" dimension of the protection mandate must always be balanced against the need to afford individual justice to the "victims, calling for a better coordination of the two concurring interests. The article focuses on how to ensure that structural violations of ECHR rights caused by defects of domestic legislation are dealt with in accordance to the principle of subsidiarity, which is at the core of the entire protection mechanism established by the Convention. After highlighting the role of subsidiarity in respect of this particular kind of violations, the author explores two possible alternative developments of the Strasbourg case-law which would contribute to strengthening the cooperation between domestic constitutional jurisdictions and the ECHR system in those States (like Italy) where individuals do not enjoy direct access to constitutional justice. Notably, the author suggests a reinterpretation of the rule of previous exhaustion of domestic remedies in order to allow national judges to assess in the first place whether a law is compatible with the ECHR; in the alternative, the Court should conclude for a violation of the right to an effective remedy under Article 13, imposing on the contracting State the obligation to provide forms of individual constitutional justice at the domestic level that would ensure the "subsidiary management" of structural violations and of the mass litigation arising thereout

Andrea Saccucci, Access to Constitutional Remedies, Previous Exhaustion and "Subsidiary" Management of ECHR Structural Violations stemming from legislative defects. in "DIRITTI UMANI E DIRITTO INTERNAZIONALE" 2/2012, pp. 263-291, DOI:10.3280/DUDI2012-002002

   

FrancoAngeli is a member of Publishers International Linking Association a not for profit orgasnization wich runs the CrossRef service, enabing links to and from online scholarly content