Clicca qui per scaricare

Fra metafisica, scienze della natura e scienze della vita. Percorsi della causalità nella filosofia scozzese del common sense
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Emanuele Levi Mortera 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2018 Fascicolo: Lingua: Italiano 
Numero pagine:  22 P. 57-78 Dimensione file:  152 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2018-001003
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 




Between Metaphysics, Natural Philosophy and Life Sciences. Aspects of Causality in the Scottish Philosophy of Common Sense. The Article focuses mainly on the internal development of the Scottish Philosophy of Common Sense through an analysis of the idea of causality as propounded by prominent figures such as Thomas Reid, Dugald Stewart and Thomas Brown. It also takes into consideration their place in the scientific and medical context of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century. The Author contends that in natural philosophy their view of causality is quite uniform in endorsing the experimental-inductive paradigm, according to which causes are considered to be the laws or rules that regulate natural phenomena. In contrast, the demarcation between the metaphysics of efficient causes and the epistemology of physical causes or laws seems to be more problematic, particularly in morals and in the life sciences. The debate initiated by these authors eventually contributed to shape the idea of causality in a more modern and quasi-positivistic way.
Keywords: Causality, common sense, physiology, Reid, Stewart and Brown

  1. - Madden 1986: Edward H. Madden, Stewart’s Enrichment of the Commonsense Tradition, «History of Philosophy Quarterly», 3 (1986), 1, pp. 45-63.
  2. - Barrantes, Durán 2016: Manuel Barrantes and Juan M. Durán, Thomas Reid on Causation and Scientific Explanation, «Journal of Scottish Philosophy», 14 (2016), 1, pp. 51-67.
  3. - Benbaji 2003: Hagit Benbaji, Reid on Causation and Action, «Journal of Scottish Philosophy», 1 (2003), 1, pp. 1-19.
  4. - Brown 1818: Thomas Brown, Inquiry into the Relation of Cause and Effect, in Thomas Dixon (ed.), Life and Collected Works of Thomas Brown, 8 vols., Thoemmes Press, Bristol 2003, vol. IV.
  5. - Brown 1820: Id., Sketch of a System of the Philosophy of the Human Mind, in Thomas Dixon (ed.), Life and Collected Works of Thomas Brown, 8 vols., Thoemmes Press, Bristol 2003, vol. V.
  6. - Brown 1828: Id., Lectures on the Philosophy of the Human Mind, in Thomas Dixon (ed.) Life and Collected Works of Thomas Brown, 8 vols., Thoemmes Press, Bristol 2003, vol. VI.
  7. - Brown 2010: Id., Selected Philosophical Writings, ed. Thomas Dixon, The Library of Scottish Philosophy, Imprint Academic, Edinburgh 2010.
  8. - Bucchi 2001: Sergio Bucchi, James Mill filosofo radicale. Analisi della mente e scienza politica nell’Inghilterra del primo Ottocento, Edizioni di Storia e Letteratura, Roma 2001.
  9. - Copenhaver 2006: Rebecca Copenhaver, Is Thomas Reid a Mysterian?, «Journal of the History of Philosophy», 44 (2006), 3, pp. 449-466.
  10. - Crombie 1793: Alexander Crombie, An Essay on Philosophical Necessity, Johnson, London 1793.
  11. - Dacey 2015: Mike Dacey, Associationism without Associative Links: Thomas Brown and the Associationist Project, «Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A», 54 (2015), pp. 31-40.
  12. - Darwin 1794: Erasmus Darwin, Zoonomia, or the Laws of Organic Life, Johnson, London 1794-1796, 2 vols.
  13. - Dessì 2012: Paola Dessì, Causa/Effetto, Il Mulino, Bologna 2012.
  14. - Dixon 2015: Thomas Dixon, Revolting against Reid: The Philosophy of Thomas Brown, in Gordon Graham (ed.), Scottish Philosophy in the Nineteenth Century & Twentieth Centuries, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015, pp. 23-46.
  15. - Dretske 1977: Frederick Dretske, Laws of Nature, «Philosophy of Science», 44 (1977), 2, pp. 248-268.
  16. - Friday 2005: Jonathan Friday, Dugald Stewart on Reid, Kant and the Refutation of Idealism, «British Journal for the History of Philosophy», 13 (2005), pp. 263-286.
  17. - Gino 2014: Sebastiano Gino, Mente, anima, sensazione. Le fonti mediche della psicologia di Thomas Reid, «Giornale dell’Accademia di medicina di Torino», Accademia di Medicina di Torino, CLXXVII (2014), pp. 397-412.
  18. - Giuntini 1984: Chiara Giuntini, Tra Hartley, Hume e Reid. La «Mental Physiology» di Thomas Brown, «Annali dell’Istituto di Filosofia», VI, Università di Firenze, Facoltà di Lettere e Filosofia, Olschki, Firenze 1984, pp. 183-215.
  19. - Giuntini 1995: Ead., La chimica della mente. Associazione delle idee e scienza della natura umana da Locke a Spencer, Le Lettere, Firenze 1995.
  20. - Godwin 1793: William Godwin, An Inquiry concerning Political Justice and its Influence on General Virtue and Happiness, 2 vols., Robinson, London 1793.
  21. - Hankins 1985: Thomas L. Hankins, Science and the Enlightenment, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1985.
  22. - Harris 2005: James A. Harris, Of Liberty and Necessity. The Free Will Debate in Eighteenth-Century British Philosophy, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2005.
  23. - Hellewell 2010: Jamie S. Hellewell, Thomas Reid on Physical Causation, «Journal of Scottish Thought», 3 (2010), pp. 41-60.
  24. - Hume 1739: David Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, eds. David F. Norton and Mary J. Norton, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2000, trad. it., Trattato sulla natura numana, in Eugenio Lecaldano (a cura di), Opere filosofiche, 4 voll., Laterza, Bari 1987, vol. I.
  25. - Levi Mortera 2007: Emanuele Levi Mortera, Associazione delle idee e senso comune, «Rivista di Filosofia», XCVIII (2007), 1, pp. 77-104.
  26. - Levi Mortera 2011: Id., Continuità e trasformazioni dell’innatismo. Dugald Stewart e la scuola scozzese del Common Sense, in Carlo Borghero, Antonella Del Prete (a cura di), Immagini filosofiche e interpretazioni storiografiche del cartesianismo, Le Lettere, Firenze 2011, pp. 195-218.
  27. - Levi Mortera 2012: Id., Stewart, Kant and the Reworking of Common Sense, «History of European Ideas», 38 (2012), 1, pp. 122-142.
  28. - Locke 1689: John Locke, An Essay concerning Human Understanding, ed. Peter H. Nidditch, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1975, trad. it. Saggio sull’intelletto umano, a cura di Marian e Nicola Abbagnano, UTET, Torino 1971.
  29. - Maione 2001: Maurizio Maione, Scienza, linguaggio, mente in Thomas Reid, Carocci, Roma 2001.
  30. - Maione 2003: Id., I filosofi scozzesi e il cervello: Hume, Reid e Brown, in Luigi Turco (a cura di), Filosofia, scienza e politica nel Settecento britannico, Il Poligrafo, Padova 2003, pp. 421-439.
  31. - McCracken 1983: Charles J. McCracken, Malebranche and British Philosophy, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1983.
  32. - Mills 1984: John A. Mills, Thomas Brown’s Theory of Causation, «Journal of the History of Philosophy», XXII (1984), 2, pp. 207-227.
  33. - Packham 2012: Catherine Packham, Eighteenth-Century Vitalism. Bodies, Culture, Politics, Palgrave Macmillan, London-New York 2012.
  34. - Paoletti 2003: Cristina Paoletti, Thomas Reid e i principi “meccanici” dell’azione, in Luigi Turco (a cura di), Filosofia, scienza e politica nel Settecento britannico, Il Poligrafo, Padova 2003, pp. 401-420
  35. - Paoletti 2006: Ead., La difesa dell’errore. Senso comune e filosofia positiva in Thomas Brown, CLUEB, Bologna 2007.
  36. - Paoletti 2011: Id., Causes as Proximate Events: Thomas Brown and the Positivist Interpretation of Hume on Causality, «Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A», 42 (2011), 1, pp. 37-44.
  37. - Reid 1764: Thomas Reid, Inquiry into the Human Mind on the Principles of Common Sense, ed. Derek R. Brooks, Pennsylvania State University Press, Pennsylvania 1997, trad. it., Ricerca sulla mente umana secondo i principi del senso comune, in Antonio Santucci (a cura di), Thomas Reid. Ricerca sulla mente umana e altri scritti, UTET, Torino 1975.
  38. - Reid 1785: Id., Essays on the Intellectual Powers of Man, ed. Derek Brooks and Knud Haakonssen, The Pennsylvania State University Press, Pennsylvania 2002, trad. it. (parziale) Saggi sui poteri intellettuali dell’uomo, in Antonio Santucci (a cura di) Thomas Reid. Ricerca sulla mente umana e altri scritti, UTET, Torino 1975.
  39. - Reid 1788: Id., Essays on the Active Powers of Man, ed. Knud Haakonssen, James A. Harris, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2010, trad. it. (parziale) Saggi sui poteri attivi dell’uomo, in Antonio Santucci (a cura di), Thomas Reid. Ricerca sulla mente umana e altri scritti, UTET, Torino 1975.
  40. - Reid 1792: Id., Of Power, «The Philosophical Quarterly», 51 (2001), pp. 1-12 e in John Haldane and Stephen Read (ed.), The Philosophy of Thomas Reid, numero special di «The Philosophical Quarterly», Blackwell, Oxford 2003, pp. 14-23.
  41. - Reid 1995: Thomas Reid on the Animate Creation. Papers Related to the Life Sciences, ed. Paul. B. Wood, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 1995.
  42. - Reid 2002: Thomas Reid, The Correspondence of Thomas Reid, ed. Paul B. Wood, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh 2002.
  43. - Reill 2005: Peter H. Reill, Vitalizing Nature in the Enlightenment, University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles 2005.
  44. - Restaino 1976: Franco Restaino, Thomas Brown, l’eretico della scuola scozzese, in Antonio Santucci (a cura di), Scienza e filosofia scozzese nell’età di Hume, Il Mulino, Bologna 1976, pp. 289-316.
  45. - Schofield 1970: Robert E. Schofield, Mechanism and Materialism. British Natural Philosophy in an Age of Reason, Princeton University Press, Princeton 1970.
  46. - Squillante 2000: Martino Squillante, Fisica e metafisica della causalità in Thomas Reid, in Antonio Santucci (a cura di), Filosofia e cultura nel Settecento Britannico, 2 voll., Il Mulino, Bologna 2000, vol. II, pp. 469-489.
  47. - Stewart 1792: Dugald Stewart, Elements of the Philosophy of the Human Mind, vol. 1, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh 1854-1860, vol. II.
  48. - Stewart 1810: Id., Philosophical Essays, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh 1854-1860, vol. V.
  49. - Stewart 1814: Id., Elements of the Philosophy of the Human Mind, vol. 2, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh, 1854-1860, vol. III.
  50. - Stewart 1815, 1821, 1854: Id., Dissertation: exhibiting the Progress of Metaphysical, Ethical and Political Philosophy since the Revival of Letters in Europe, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh, 1854-1860, vol. I.
  51. - Stewart 1827: Id., Elements of the philosophy of the Human Mind, vol. 3, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh, 1854-1860, vol. IV.
  52. - Stewart 1828: Id., The Philosophy of the Active and Moral Powers of Man, in William Hamilton (ed.), The Collected Works of Dugald Stewart, 11 vols., Edinburgh, 1854-1860, vol. VII.
  53. - Tuggy 2000: Dale Tuggy, Thomas Reid on Causation, «Reid Studies», 3 (2000), 2, pp. 3-28.
  54. - Whewell 1840: William Whewell, The Philosophy of the Inductive Sciences, repr. with a new introduction by Andrew Pyle, Routledge-Thoemmes Press, Bristol 1996.
  55. - Whytt 1751: Robert Whytt, An Essay On the Vital and Other Involuntary Motions of Animals, Hamilton, Edinburgh 1751.
  56. - Wood 2015: Paul B. Wood, Thomas Reid and the Common Sense School. With a Postscript, in Aaaron Garrett, James A. Harris (eds.), Scottish Philosophy in the Eighteenth Century. Volume I: Morals, Politics, Art, Religion, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015, pp. 404-467.

Emanuele Levi Mortera, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 1/2018, pp. 57-78, DOI:10.3280/SF2018-001003

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche