Click here to download

Labour Mobility and Social Dumping in Europe, Today
Journal Title: GIORNALE DI DIRITTO DEL LAVORO E DI RELAZIONI INDUSTRIALI  
Author/s: Stefano Giubboni, Giovanni Orlandini 
Year:  2018 Issue: 160 Language: Italian 
Pages:  40 Pg. 907-946 FullText PDF:  377 KB
DOI:  10.3280/GDL2018-160010
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:  clicca qui   and here 


The article offers a critical appraisal of the uneven evolution of the EU law on transnational postings of workers in the context of the "new" political economy of the internal market.
Keywords: Internal market; Labour mobility; Social dumping; European crisis.

  1. Ales E. (2016). Alla ricerca dei limiti giuridici alla condizionalità politica: luci e ombre della dimensione costituzionale del Modello Sociale Europeo. In: Bergonzoni C., Borelli S., Guazzarotti A., a cura di, La legge dei numeri. Governance economica e marginalizzazione dei diritti. Napoli: Jovene.
  2. Allamprese A. (2006). Distacco dei lavoratori stranieri in Italia nel quadro di una prestazione transnazionale di servizi: profili previdenziali. PAPP, I: 1 ss.
  3. Baccaro L., Howell C. (2017). Trajectories of Neoliberal Transformation. European Industrial Relations since the 1970s. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  4. Bano F. (2015). La territorialità del diritto. Distacco transnazionale di manodopera a basso costo. LD: 583 ss.
  5. Barnard C. (2011). The Notion of Abuse and Freedom to Provide Services: A Labour Lawyer’s Perspective. In: De la Feria R., Vogenauer S., eds., Prohibition of Abuse of Law. A New General Principle of EU Law?. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing, 93 ss.
  6. Barnard C. (2012). A Proportionate Response to Proportionality in the Field of Collective Action. ELR, 37: 117 ss.
  7. Barnard C. (2016). The Substantive Law of the EU. The Four Freedoms. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  8. Bratton W., McCahery J., Picciotto S., Scott C., eds. (1996). International Regulatory Competition and Coordination. Perspectives on Economic Regulation in Europe and the United States. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  9. Bruun N., Bücker A., Dorssemont F. (2012). Balancing Fundamental Rights and Economic Freedoms: Can the Monti II Initiative Solve the EU Dilemma?. IJCLLIR, 28(3): 279 ss.
  10. Bruun N., Malberg J. (2011). Lex Laval. Collective Actions and Posted Workers in Sweden. In: Blanpain R., Hendrickx F., eds., Labour Law between Change and Tradition. Liber Amicorum Antoine Jacobs. Alphen an de Rijn: Kluwer Law International.
  11. Carabelli U. (2009). Europa dei mercati e conflitto sociale. Bari: Cacucci.
  12. Cinelli M. (2007). Distacco e previdenza nella prestazione transnazionale di servizi. LG: 124 ss.
  13. Countouris N., Engblom S. (2015). Protection or Protectionism? – A Legal Deconstruction of the Emerging False Dilemma in European Integration. UCL Labour Rights Institute On-line Working Papers – LRI WP 1/2015.
  14. Corti M. (2016). Concorrenza e lavoro: incroci pericolosi in attesa di una svolta. DLRI: 505 ss.
  15. Davies P. (1997). Single Market or Protection of National Labour Systems?. CMLR, 34(3): 571 ss.
  16. Defossez A. (2014). Le dumping social dans l’Union européenne. Bruxelles: Larcier.
  17. Koukiadaki A. (2014). The Far-Reaching Implication of the Laval Quartet: The Case of the UK Living Wage. ILJ, 43(2): 91 ss.
  18. Defossez A. (2018). Directive 2014/67/EU on the enforcement of Directive 96/71/EC concerning the posting of workers in the framework of the provision of services. In Ales E., Bell M., Deinert O., Robin-Olivier S., eds., International and European Labour Law. Article-by-Article Commentary. Baden-Baden: C.H. Beck-Hart-Nomos.
  19. De la Feria R., Vogenauer S., eds. (2011). Prohibition of Abuse of Law. A New General Principle of EU Law?. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  20. De Witte F. (2017). The Constitutional Quality of the Free Movement Provisions: Looking for Context in the Case Law on Article 56 TFEU. ELR, 42(3): 313 ss.
  21. Dorssemont F. (2013). The Right to Take Collective Action under Article 11 ECHR. In: Dorssemont F., Lörcher, Schömann I., eds., The European Convention on Human Rights and the Employment Relation. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  22. Dorssemont F., Orlandini G. (2014). Market Rules and the Right to Strike: A Different Approach. In: Rigaux M., Buelens J., Latinne A., eds., From Labour Law to Social Competition Law?. Cambridge-Antwerp: Intersentia.
  23. Eriksen E.O. (2017). Structural Injustice and Solidarity. The Case of the Eurozone Crisis. ARENA Working Paper, 4/2017.
  24. Esty D.C., Geradin D., eds. (2001). Regulatory Competition and Economic Integration. Comparative Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  25. Ferrera M. (2005). The Boundaries of Welfare. European Integration and the New Spatial Politics of Social Protection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  26. Ferrera M. (2018). Si può costruire una Unione sociale europea?. QC: 567 ss.
  27. Fligstein N. (2009). Euro-clash. The EU, European Identity, and the Future of Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  28. Foucault M. (2009). Il governo di sé e degli altri. Corso al Collège de France (1982-1983). Trad. it., Milano: Feltrinelli.
  29. Freedland M., Prassl J., eds. (2016). Viking, Laval and Beyond. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  30. Garben S. (2017). The Constitutional (Im)balance between «the Market» and «the Social» in the European Union. ECLR, 13(1): 23 ss.
  31. Giubboni S. (2003). Diritti sociali e mercato. La dimensione sociale dell’integrazione europea. Bologna: il Mulino.
  32. Giubboni S. (2012). Diritti e solidarietà in Europa. Bologna: il Mulino.
  33. Giubboni S. (2017). Diritto del lavoro europeo. Una introduzione critica. Padova: Cedam.
  34. Giubboni, S. (2018a). La solidarietà come «scudo». Il tramonto della cittadinanza sociale transnazionale nella crisi europea. QC: 585 ss.
  35. Giubboni S. (2018b). The New European Labour Authority and Social Security Coordination. Some Preliminary Remarks. RDSS: 521 ss.
  36. Giubboni S., Iudicone L., Mancini M., Faioli M. (2017). Coordination of Social Security Systems in Europe. Study for the EMPL Committee. Directorate General for Internal Policies – Policy Department A) Economic and Scientific Policy, European Parliament. Luxembourg: EU Publication Office.
  37. Giubboni S., Orlandini G. (2007). La libera circolazione dei lavoratori nell’Unione europea. Bologna: il Mulino.
  38. Izzi D. (2018). Lavoro negli appalti e dumping salariale. Torino: Giappichelli.
  39. Kamanabrou S. (2018). Abuse of Law in the Context of EU Law. ELR, 43: 534 ss.
  40. Kilpatrick C. (2009). Laval’s Regulatory Conundrum: Collective Standard-Setting and the Court’s New Approach to Posted Workers. ELR, 34(6): 844 ss.
  41. Lhernould J.-Ph. (2007), Les entreprises face à la coordination européenne des régimes nationaux de Sécurité sociale: l’autre côté du miroir. DS: 225 ss.
  42. Lo Faro A. (2010). Diritto al conflitto e conflitto di diritti nel mercato unico: lo sciopero al tempo della libera circolazione. RDPE: 45 ss.
  43. Loffredo A. (2018). Democrazia aziendale, imprese transnazionali e dumping sociale. Napoli: Editoriale Scientifica.
  44. Luther J. (2013). La dottrina generale di Kelsen in Italia semper docet?. In: Kelsen H., Dottrina generale dello Stato. Trad. it. Milano: Giuffrè.
  45. Lyon-Caen G. (1992). L’infiltration du Droit du travail par le Droit de la concurrence. DO: 313 ss.
  46. Menéndez A.J. (2018). Not Seven, But Eleven? European Crises or «New Normal»?. ELJ, 24(1): 2 ss.
  47. Mengozzi P. (2009). I conflitti di legge, le norme di applicazione necessaria in materia di rapporti di lavoro e la libertà di circolazione dei servizi nella Comunità europea. In: Venturini G., Bariatti S., a cura di, Nuovi strumenti del diritto internazionale privato. Liber Fausto Pocar. Milano: Giuffrè.
  48. Mucha A., Oplustil K. (2018). Redefining the Freedom of Establishment under EU Law as the Freedom to Choose Applicable Company Law: A Discussion after Judgment of the Court of Justice (Grand Chamber) of 25 October 2017 in Case C-106/17, Polbud. ECFLR: 270 ss.
  49. Murphy D.D. (2004). The Structure of Regulatory Competition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  50. Nicolussi A. (2006). Europa e cosiddetta competizione tra ordinamenti giuridici. EDP, 1: 83 ss.
  51. Orlandini G. (2003). Sciopero e servizi pubblici essenziali nel processo d’integrazione europea. Uno studio di diritto comparato e comunitario. Torino: Giappichelli.
  52. Orlandini G. (2012). Il lavoro con elementi di internazionalità. WP CSDLE “Massimo D’Antona”.IT, 137/2012. -- Testo disponibile al sito: http://csdle.lex.unict.it/docs/workingpapers/Il-rapporto-lavoro-con-elementi-di-internazionalit/2345.aspx (consultato il 2.8.2018).
  53. Orlandini G. (2013). Mercato unico dei servizi e tutela del lavoro. Milano: Franco Angeli.
  54. Paju J. (2017). The European Union and Social Security Law. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  55. Pallini M. (2016). Diritto europeo e limiti di ammissibilità delle clausole sociali nella regolazione nazionale degli appalti pubblici di opere e servizi. DLRI: 525 ss.
  56. Pallini M. (2017). Gli appalti transnazionali: la disciplina italiana al vaglio di conformità con il diritto europeo. RGL, I: 485 ss.
  57. Pallini M. (2018). Article 56 TFUE. In: Ales E., Bell M., Deinert O., Robin-Olivier S., eds., International and European Labour Law. Article-by-Article Commentary. Baden-Baden: C.H. Beck-Hart-Nomos.
  58. Pataut E. (2018). Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 on the Law Applicable to Contractual Obligations (Rome I) - Articles 8 and 9. In: Ales E., Bell M., Deinert O., Robin-Olivier S., eds., International and European Labour Law. Article-by-Article Commentary. Baden-Baden: C.H. Beck-Hart-Nomos.
  59. Pecinovsky P. (2016). Evolutions in the Social Case Law of the Court of Justice. The Follow-Up Cases of the Laval Quartet: ESA and RegioPost. ELLJ, 7(2): 292 ss.
  60. Pennings F. (2015). European Social Security Law. Cambridge-Antwerp: Intersentia (6th edition).
  61. Poiares Maduro M. (2001). Never on Sunday – What Has (EU) Law Got to Do with It?. In: Sciarra S., ed., Labour Law in the Courts. National Judges and the European Court of Justice. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  62. Rocca M. (2015). Posting of Workers and Collective Labour Law: There and Back Again. Cambridge-Antwerp: Intersentia.
  63. Rodotà S. (2014). Solidarietà. Un’utopia necessaria. Roma-Bari: Laterza.
  64. Sánchez Graells A., eds. (2017). Smart Public Procurement and Labour Standards. Pushing the Discussion after RegioPost. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  65. Saydé A. (2014). Abuse of EU Law and Regulation of Internal Market. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  66. Scharpf F.W. (1999). Governare l’Europa. Legittimità democratica ed efficacia delle politiche dell’Unione europea. Trad. it. Bologna: il Mulino.
  67. Scharpf F.W. (2016). Europa. La democrazia sospesa. Firenze: GoWare.
  68. Sciarra S. (1995). Social Values and Multiple Sources in European Social Law. ELJ, 1(1): 60 ss.
  69. Sciarra S. (2003). Market Freedom and Fundamental Social Rights. In: Hepple B., ed., Social and Labour Rights in a Global Context. International and Comparative Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  70. Sciarra S. (2008). Viking e Laval: diritti collettivi e mercato nel recente dibattito europeo. LD: 245 ss.
  71. Sciarra S. (2012). Un confronto a distanza: il diritto di sciopero nell’ordinamento globale. PD: 231 ss.
  72. Sciarra S. (2013). L’Europa e il lavoro. Solidarietà e conflitto in tempo di crisi. Roma-Bari: Laterza.
  73. Sciarra S. (2018). Solidarity and Conflict. European Social Law in Crisis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  74. Snyder F. (1995). Editorial. ELJ, 1(1): 1 ss.
  75. Sørensen K. (2015). The Fight Against Letterbox Companies in the Internal Market. CMLR, 52(1): 85 ss.
  76. Steinmeyer H.-D. (2015). Article 12. In: Fuchs M., Cornelissen R., eds., EU Social Security Law. A Commentary on Regulations 883/2004 and 987/2009. Baden-Baden: C.H. Beck, Hart, Nomos.
  77. Streeck W. (2018). Taking Back Control? The Future of Western Democratic Capitalism. EJER, 1(3): 30 ss.
  78. Supiot A. (2005). Le droit du travail bradé sur le «marché des normes». DS : 1087 ss.
  79. Syrpis P. (2016), EU Secondary Legislation and its Impact on Derogations from Free Movement. In: Koutrakos P., Shuibhne N.N., Syrpis P., eds., Exceptions from EU Free Movement Law. Derogation, Justification and Proportionality. Oxford and Portland, Oregon: Hart Publishing.
  80. Syrpis P., Novitz T. (2015). The EU Internal Market and Domestic Labour Law: Looking Beyond Autonomy. In: Bogg. A., Costello C., Davies A.C.L., Prassl J., eds., The Autonomy of Labour Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 291 ss.
  81. Torchia L. (2006). Il governo delle differenze. Il principio di equivalenza nell’ordinamento europeo. Bologna: il Mulino.
  82. Tridimas T. (2018). General Principles of EU Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press (3rd edition).
  83. Trstenjak V., Beysen E. (2013). The Growing Overlap of Fundamental Freedoms and Fundamental Rights in the Case Law of the CJEU. ELR, 38(3): 293 ss.
  84. Tryfonidou A. (2016). The Impact of Union Citizenship on the EU’s Market Freedoms. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.
  85. Van Hoek A.H. (2018). Re-Embedding the Transnational Employment Relationship: A Tale About the Limitation of (EU) Law? CMLR, 55: 449 ss.
  86. Van Hoek A.H., Houwerzijl M. (2016). Where Do EU Mobile Workers Belong, According to Rome I and the (E)PWD?. In: Verschueren H., ed., Residence, Employment and Social Rights of Mobile Persons: on How EU Law Defines where They Belong. Cambridge: Intersentia.
  87. Weiler J.H.H. (1994). The Quiet Revolution: The European Court of Justice and its Interlocutors. CPS, 26(4): 510 ss.
  88. Wheatherill S. (2011). Fitting «Abuse of Rights» into EU Law Governing the Free Movement of Goods and Services. In: De la Feria R., Vogenauer S., eds., Prohibition of Abuse of Law. A New General Principle of EU Law?. Oxford-Portland (Oregon): Hart Publishing.

Stefano Giubboni, Giovanni Orlandini, Labour Mobility and Social Dumping in Europe, Today in "GIORNALE DI DIRITTO DEL LAVORO E DI RELAZIONI INDUSTRIALI " 160/2018, pp. 907-946, DOI:10.3280/GDL2018-160010

   

FrancoAngeli is a member of Publishers International Linking Association a not for profit orgasnization wich runs the CrossRef service, enabing links to and from online scholarly content