Click here to download

Pain and emotions in non-human animals: Debates and insights from philosophy, ethology, and neuroscience
Author/s: Maria Elide Vanutelli, Michela Balconi 
Year:  2019 Issue: Language: English 
Pages:  32 Pg. 385-416 FullText PDF:  279 KB
DOI:  10.3280/RIP2019-002008
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:  clicca qui   and here 

The experience of pain can be referred verbally by human subjects and, although this criterion is considered during scientific and medical procedures, it appears evident that the same principle cannot be applied to other species. Thus, pain in animals is usually inferred by non-verbal behaviors, but this inference is not, or should not be that simple to make. In the present work available philosophical, ethological and neuroscientific resources about the experience of pain in humans and animals will be reviewed, to explore continuities and specificities by a comparative perspective. Also, a new framework will be proposed to highlight some significant behaviors related to pain experience within the animal kingdom. In detail, we suggest that by observing and analyzing complex emotional and social (shared) experiences related to pain it would be possible to infer, at least in some cases, the presence of a subjective experience of pain.
Keywords: Pain; emotions, animals, human being, empathy.

  1. Aitken, G. (2008). Animal Suffering : An Evolutionary Approach. Environmental Values, 17, 165-180., DOI: 10.3197/096327108X303837
  2. Allen, C. (2004). Animal pain. Nous, 38(4), 617-643.
  3. Anil, S. S., Anil, L., & Deen, J. (2002). Challenges of pain assessment in domestic animals. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 220(3), 313-319.
  4. Appel, M., & Elwood, R. W. (2009). Motivational trade-offs and potential pain experience in hermit crabs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 119(1-2), 120-124.
  5. Atsak, P., Orre, M., Bakker, P., Cerliani, L., Roozendaal, B., Gazzola, V., Keysers, C. (2011). Experience modulates vicarious freezing in rats: A model for empathy. PLoS ONE, 6(7), e21855.
  6. Balconi, M., & Bortolotti, A. (2012). Empathy in cooperative versus non-cooperative situations: The contribution of self-report measures and autonomic responses. Applied Psychophysiology Biofeedback, 37(3), 161-169.
  7. Balconi, M., & Vanutelli, M. E. (2015). Emotions and BIS/BAS components affect brain activity (ERPs and fNIRS) in observing intra-species and inter-spe cies interactions. Brain Imaging and Behavior.
  8. Balconi, M., & Vanutelli, M. E. (2017a). Empathy in negative and positive interpersonal interactions. What is the relationship between central (EEG, fNIRS) and peripheral (autonomic) neurophysiological responses? Advances in Cognitive Psychology, 13(1), 105-120.
  9. Balconi, M., & Vanutelli, M. E. (2017b). When cooperation was efficient or inefficient. Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy evidence. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 11, 26.
  10. Balderrama, N., Diaz, H., Sequeda, A., Nunez, J., & Maldonado, H. (1987). Behavioral and pharmacological analysis of the stinging response in africanized and italian bees. In R. Menzel & A. Mercer (Eds.), Neurobiology and Behavior of Honeybees (pp. 121-128). New York: Springer- Verlag.
  11. Bates, L. A., Lee, P. C., Njiraini, N., Poole, J. H., Sayialel, K., Sayialel, S., Byrne, R. W. (2008). Do elephants show empathy? Journal of Consciousness Studies, 15(10-11), 204-225.
  12. Bateson, P. (1991). Assessment of pain in animals. Animal Behaviour, 42(5), 827-839., DOI: 10.1016/S0003-3472(05)80127-7
  13. Bekoff, M. (2000). The smile of a dolphin: Remarkable accounts of animal emotions. New York: Random House/Discovery Books.
  14. Bekoff, M. (2006). Animal Emotions: Exploring Passionate Natures. BioScience, 50(10), 861-870.
  15. Bermond, B. (2001). A neuropsychological and evolutionary approach to animal consciousness and animal suffering. Animal Welfare, 10, S47-S62.
  16. Boly, M., Garrido, M. I., Gosseries, O., Bruno, M., Laureys, S., & Friston, K. (2011). Preserved feedforward but impaired top-down processes in the vegetative state. Science, 332, 858-862.
  17. Braithwaite, V. A., & Huntingford, F. A. (2004). Fish and welfare: Do fish have the capacity for pain perception and suffering? Animal Welfare, 13, S87-S92.
  18. Bredy, T. W., & Barad, M. (2009). Social modulation of associative fear learning by pheromone communication. Learning & Memory, 16(1), 12-18.
  19. Bromm, B., & Lorenz, J. (1998). Neurophysiological evaluation of pain. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 107, 227-253., DOI: 10.1016/S0013-4694(98)00075-3
  20. Broom, D. M. (2001). The evolution of pain. Vlaams Diergeneeskundig Tijdschrift, 70(1), 17-21.
  21. Broom, D. M. (2014). Sentience and Animal Welfare. Wallingford: CABI.
  22. Broom, D. M. (2016). Fish Brains and Behaviour Indicate Capacity for Feeling Pain. Animal Sentience, 10(Commentary on Key on Fish Pain), 1-6.
  23. Cabanac, M., Cabanac, A. J., & Parent, A. (2009). The emergence of consciousness in phylogeny. Behavioural Brain Research, 198(2), 267-272.
  24. Carruthers, P. (2000). Phenomenal Consciousness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  25. Chandroo, K. P., Duncan, I. J. H., & Moccia, R. D. (2004). Can fish suffer?: Per spectives on sentience, pain, fear and stress. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 86(3-4), 225-250.
  26. Changeux, J.-P. (2012). Conscious processing: implications for general anesthesia. Curr e n t Op i n i o n i n A n e s t h e s i o l o g y, 25, 3 9 8 - 4 0 4 . D O I : 10.1097/ACO.0b013e32835561de.
  27. Chapman, C. R. (1992). Suffering in animals: towards comprehensive definition and measurement for animal care. In T. R. Kuchel, M. Rose, & J. Burrell (Eds.), Animal Pain Ethical and Scientific Perspectives (pp. 19-25). Australian and New Zealand Council for the Care of Animals in Research and Teaching.
  28. Church, R. M. (1959). Emotional reactions of rats to the pain of others. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 52(2), 132-134.
  29. Constant, I., & Sabourdin, N. (2015). Monitoring depth of anesthesia: from consciousness to nociception. A window on subcortical brain activity. Paediatric Anaesthesia, 25(1), 73-82.
  30. Danbury, T. C., Weeks, C. A., Waterman-Pearson, A. E., Kestin, S. C., & Chambers, J. P. (2000). Self-selection of the analgesic drug carprofen by lame broiler chickens. Veterinary Record, 146(11), 307-311.
  31. Darwin, C. (1982). The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
  32. Dawkins, M. S. (2012). Why animals matter: Animal consciousness, animal welfare, and human well-being. New York: Oxford University Press.
  33. de Waal, F. B. M. (1997). Are we in anthropodenial? Discover, 18(7), 505-3.
  34. de Waal, F. B. M. (2008). Putting the altruism back into altruism: the evolution of empathy. Annual Review of Psychology, 59, 279-300.
  35. de Waal, F. B. M., & Aureli, F. (1996). Consolation, reconciliation, and a possible cognitive difference between macaque and chimpanzee. In A. E. Russon,
  36. K. A. Bard, & S. T. Parker (Eds.), Reaching into Thought: The Minds of the Great Apes (pp. 80-110). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  37. de Waal, F. B. M., & van Roosmalen, A. (1979). Reconciliation and consolation among chimpanzees. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, (5), 55-66., DOI: 10.1007/BF00302695
  38. Denzer, D., & Laudien, H. (1987). Stress induced biosynthesis of a 31 kd-glycoprotein in goldfish brain. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology. B, Comparative Biochemistry, 86(3), 555-559., DOI: 10.1016/0305-0491(87)90447-0
  39. Douglas-Hamilton, I., Bhalla, S., Wittemyer, G., & Vollrath, F. (2006). Behavioural reactions of elephants towards a dying and deceased matriarch. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 100(1-2), 87-102.
  40. Downes, H., Koop, D. R., Klopfenstein, B., & Lessov, N. (1999). Retention of nociceptor responses during deep barbiturate anesthesia in frogs. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part C: Pharmacology Toxicology and Endocrinology, 124(2), 203-210., DOI: 10.1016/S0742-8413(99)00069-9
  41. Duncan, I. J. H., & Fraser, D. (1997). Understanding animal welfare. In M. C. Appleby & B. O. Hughes (Eds.), Animal Welfare, CAB International (pp. 19- 31). Cambridge: University Press.
  42. Edgar, J. L., Lowe, J. C., Paul, E. S., & Nicol, C. J. (2011). Avian maternal response to chick distress. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 278(1721), 3129-3134.
  43. Elwood, R. W. (2018). Pain and suffering in invertebrates? ILAR Journal, 52(2), 175-184.
  44. Ferdowsian, H. (2012). Parallels in sources of trauma, pain, distress, and suffering in humans and nonhuman animals, 13(4), 448-468., DOI: 10.1080/15299732.2011.652346
  45. Gallup, G. G. J. (1970). Chimpanzees: Self-recognition. Science, 167, 86-87.
  46. Gallup, G. G. J. (1998). Can animals empathize? Yes. Scientific American, 9, 66-71.
  47. Gallup, G. G. J., Anderson, J. R., & Shillito, D. J. (2002). The Mirror Test. In M.
  48. Bekoff, C. Allen, & G. M. Burghardt (Eds.), The Cognitive Animal (pp. 325-334). Cambridge: MIT Press.
  49. Garcia-Larrea, L., Charles, N., Sindou, M., & Mauguiere, F. (1993). Flexion reflexes following anterolateral cordotomy in man: dissociation between pain sensation and nociceptive reflex RIII. Pain, 139, 149., DOI: 10.1016/0304-3959(93)90143-D
  50. Gentle, M. J. (2001). Attentional shifts alter pain perception in the chicken. Animal Welfare, 10, S187-S194.
  51. Godfrey-Smith, P. (2016). Other minds: The octopus and the evolution of intelligent life. London: William Collins.
  52. Goetz, J. L., Keltner, D., & Simon-Thomas, E. (2010). Compassion: an evolutionary analysis and empirical review. Psychological Bulletin, 136, 351-374.
  53. Gonzalez-Liencres, C., Shamay-Tsoory, S. G., & Brune, M. (2013). Towards a neuroscience of empathy: Ontogeny, phylogeny, brain mechanisms, context and psychopathology. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 37(8), 1537-1548.
  54. Gregory, N. C. (2004). Physiology and behaviour of animal suffering. New York: Wiley.
  55. Hadjistavropoulos, T., Craig, K. D., Duck, S., Cano, A., Goubert, L., Jackson, P. L., Williams, A. C. de C. (2011). A biopsychosocial formulation of pain communication. Psychological Bulletin, 137(6), 910.
  56. Haikonen, P. O. (2016). On the sentience of fish. Animal Sentience Haikonen Commentary on Key on Fish Pain, 10(Commentary on Key on Fish Pain), 1-2.
  57. Ham, J., & Tronick, E. (2009). Relational psychophysiology: lessons from mother-infant physiology research on dyadically expanded states of consciousness. Psychotherapy Research : Journal of the Society for Psychotherapy Research, 19(6), 619-632., DOI: 10.1080/10503300802609672
  58. Hecht, E. E., Patterson, R., & Barbey, A. K. (2012). What can other animals tell us about human social cognition? An evolutionary perspective on reflective and reflexive processing. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 6, 1-13.
  59. IASP. (1979). Pain terms: A list with definitions and notes on usage. Pain, 6, 247-252.
  60. Jeon, D., Kim, S., Chetana, M., Jo, D., Ruley, H. E., Lin, S.-Y., … Shin, H.-S. (2010). Observational fear learning involves affective pain system and Cav1.2 Ca2+ channels in ACC. Nature Neuroscience, 13(4), 482-8.
  61. Key, B. (2016). Why fish do not feel pain. Animal Sentience, 3(Key on Fish Pain), 1-33.
  62. Kim, E. J., Kim, E. S., Covey, E., & Kim, J. J. (2010). Social transmission of fear in rats: The role of 22-kHz ultrasonic distress vocalization. PLoS ONE, 5(12), e15077.
  63. Knapska, E., Mikosz, M., Werka, T., & Maren, S. (2009). Social modulation of learning in rats. Learning and Memory, 17, 35-42.
  64. Langford, D. J., Crager, S. E., Shehzad, Z., Smith, S. B., Sotocinal, S. G., Levenstadt, J. S., … Mogil, J. S. (2006). Social modulation of pain as evidence for empathy in mice. Science, 312(5782), 1967-1970.
  65. Langford, D. J., Tuttle, A. H., Brown, K., Deschenes, S., Fischer, D. B., Mutso, A., … Sternberg, W. F. (2009). Social approach to pain in laboratory mice. Social Neuroscience, 5, 163-170., DOI: 10.1080/17470910903216609
  66. Lorenz, K. Z. (1991). Here I Am-Where Are You? New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
  67. Low, P. (2013). The Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness. In J. Panksepp, D. Ross, D. Edelman, B. Van Swinderen, & C. Koch (Eds.). Francis Crick Memorial Conference, University of Cambridge. 19th November 2012.
  68. Lumley, M. A., Cohen, J. L., Borszcz, G. S., Cano, A., Radcliffe, A. M., Porter, L. S., … Keefe, F. J. (2011). Pain and emotion: A biopsychosocial review of recent research. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 67(9), 942-968.
  69. Martin, A. R., & Wickelgren, W. O. (1971). Sensory cells in the spinal cord of the sea lamprey. The Journal of Physiology, 212(1), 65-83.
  70. Masserman, J., Wechkin, M. S., & Terris, W. (1964). Altruistic behavior in rhesus monkeys. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 121, 584-585.
  71. McComb, K., Baker, L., & Moss, C. (2006). African elephants show high levels of interest in the skulls and ivory of their own species. Biology Letters, 2(1), 26-28.
  72. Millsopp, S., & Laming, P. (2008). Trade-offs between feeding and shock avoidance in goldfish (Carassius auratus). Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 113(1-3), 247-254.
  73. Mogil, J. S. (2015). Social modulation of and by pain in humans and rodents. Pain, 156(4), S35-S41.
  74. Mroczek, N. S. (1992). Point of view: Recognizing animal suffering and pain.
  75. Lab Animal, 21(9), 27-30. Muto, A., Ohkura, M., Abe, G., Nakai, J., & Kawakami, K. (2013). Real-time visualization of neuronal activity during perception. Current Biology, 23(4), 307-311.
  76. National Research Council (US) Committee on recognition and alleviation of pain in laboratory animals. (2009). Pain in research animals: General principles and considerations. In Recognition and Alleviation of Pain in Laboratory Animals (National A, p. 1). Washington (DC).
  77. Nelkin, N. (1986). Pains and pain sensation. The Journal of Philosophy, 83(3), 129-148., DOI: 10.2307/2026571
  78. Nordgreen, J., Garner, J. P., Janczak, A. M., Ranheim, B., Muir, W. M., & Horsberg, T. E. (2009). Thermonociception in fish: effects of two different doses of morphine on thermal threshold and post-test behaviour in goldfish (Carassius auratus). Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 119(1-2), 101-107.
  79. Norman, G. J., Karelina, K., Morris, J. S., Zhang, N., Cochran, M., & DeVries, A. C. (2010). Social interaction prevents the development of depressive-like behavior post nerve injury in mice: a potential role for oxytocin. Psychosomatic Medicine, 72(6), 519-526.
  80. Panksepp, J., Normansell, L., Cox, J. F., & Siviy, S. M. (1994). Effects of neonatal decortication on the social play of juvenile rats. Physiology & Behavior, 56(3), 429-443., DOI: 10.1016/0031-9384(94)90285-2
  81. Panksepp, J., & Panksepp, J. B. (2013). Toward a cross-species understanding of e m p a t h y . Trends in Neurosciences, 36( 8 ) , 4 8 9 - 4 9 6 . DOI : 10.1016/j.tins.2013.04.009.
  82. Pernick, M. S. (1985). A calculus of suffering: Pain, professionalism and anesthesia in Nineteenth Century America. New York: Columbia University Press.
  83. Poole, J. (1998). An exploration of a commonality between ourselves and elephants. Etica & Animali, 9(98), 85-110.
  84. Portavella, M. (2004). Avoidance response in Goldfish: Emotional and temporal involvement of medial and lateral telencephalic pallium. Journal of Neuroscience, 24(9), 2335-2342., DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4930-03.2004
  85. Preston, S. D., & de Waal, F. B. M. (2002a). Empathy: its ultimate and proximate bases. The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 25(1), 1-20., DOI: 10.1017/S0140525-X02000018
  86. Preston, S. D., & de Waal, F. B. M. (2002b). The communication of emotions and the possibility of empathy in animals. In S. G. Post, L. G. Underwood, J. P. Schloss, & W. B. Hurlbut (Eds.), Altruistic Love: Science, Philosophy, and Religion in Dialogue (pp. 284-308). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  87. Reed, R. G., Randall, A. K., Post, J. H., & Butler, E. A. (2013). Partner influence and in-phase versus anti-phase physiological linkage in romantic couples. International Journal of Psychophysiology, 88(3), 309-316.
  88. Rowan, A. N. (1988). Animal anxiety and animal suffering, 20, 135-142. Searle, J. (1994). Animal Minds. Midwest Studies In Philosophy, 19(1), 206-219.
  89. Seth, A. K., Baars, B. J., & Edelman, D. B. (2005). Criteria for consciousness in humans and other mammals. Consciousness and Cognition, 14(1), 119–139.
  90. Shumaker, R., & Swartz, K. (2002). When traditional methodologies fail: Cognitive studies of great apes. In M. Bekoff, C. Allen, & G. M. Burghardt (Eds.), The Cognitive Animal (pp. 335–344). Cambridge: MIT Press.
  91. Shutt, D. A., Fell, L. R., Connell, R., Bell, A. K., Wallace, C. A., & Smith, A. I. (1987). Stress-induced changes in plasma concentrations of immunoreactive s-Endorphin and cortisol in response to routine surgical procedures in lambs. Australian Journal of Biological Sciences, 40(1), 97-104., DOI: 10.1071/BI9870097
  92. Singer, T., & Lamm, C. (2009). The social neuroscience of empathy. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1156(1), 81-96.
  93. Smith, T. W., Cribbet, M. R., Nealey-Moore, J. B., Uchino, B. N., Williams, P. G., Mackenzie, J., & Thayer, J. F. (2011). Matters of the variable heart: respiratory sinus arrhythmia response to marital interaction and associations with marital quality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100(1), 103-19.
  94. Sneddon, L. U. (2003). The evidence for pain in fish: the use of morphine as an analgesic. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 83(2), 153-162., DOI: 10.1016/S0168-1591(03)00113-8
  95. Sneddon, L. U. (2016). Anthropomorphic denial of fish pain. Animal Sentience, 10(Commentary on Key on fish Pain), 1-4.
  96. Tye, M. (2000). Consciousness, Color, and Content. Cambridge: MIT Press.
  97. Tye, M. (2016). Tense bees and shell-shocked crabs: Are animals conscious? New York: Oxford University Press.
  98. Vanutelli, M. E., & Balconi, M. (2015a). Empathy and Prosocial Behaviours. Insights from Intra- and Inter-species Interactions. Rivista Internazionale Di Filosofia e Psicologia, 6(1), 88-109.
  99. Vanutelli, M. E., & Balconi, M. (2015b). Perceiving emotions in human–human and human–animal interactions: Hemodynamic prefrontal activity (fNIRS) and empathic concern. Neuroscience Letters, 605, 1-6.
  100. Vanutelli, M. E., Gatti, L., Angioletti, L., & Balconi, M. (2017). Affective Synchrony and Autonomic Coupling during Cooperation : A Hyperscanning Study. BioMed Research International, 2017., DOI: 10.1155/2017/3104564
  101. Vanutelli, M. E., Nandrino, J.-L., & Balconi, M. (2016). The boundaries of cooperation: Sharing and coupling from ethology to neuroscience. Neuropsychological Trends, 19(1).
  102. Varner, G. (1998). In nature’s interests? Interests, animal rights, and environmental ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
  103. Wall, P. D. (1979). On the relation of injury to pain. Pain, 6(3), 253-264., DOI: 10.1016/0304-3959(79)90047-2.
  104. Wall, P. D. (1992). Defining “pain in animals.” In C. E. Short & A. van Poznak (Eds.), Animal pain (pp. 63-79). New York: Churchill Livingstone.
  105. Watanabe, S., & Ono, K. (1986). An experimental analysis of “empathic” response: effects of pain reactions of pigeon upon other pigeon’s operant behavior. Behavioural Processes, 13, 269-277., DOI: 10.1016/0376-6357(86)90089-6
  106. Weary, D. M., Niel, L., Flower, F. C., & Fraser, D. (2006). Identifying and preventing pain in animals. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 100(1-2), 64-76.
  107. Wechkin, S., Masserman, J. H., & Terris, W. (1964). Shock to a conspecific as an aversive stimulus. Psychonomic Science, 1, 47-48., DOI: 10.3758/BF03342783
  108. Wohr, M., & Schwarting, R. K. W. (2008). Ultrasonic calling during fear conditioning in the rat: no evidence for an audience effect. Animal Behaviour, 76(3), 749-760.
  109. Zahn-Waxler, C., Hollenbeck, B., & Radke-Yarrow, M. (1984). The origins of empathy and altruism. In M. W. Fox & L. D. Mickley (Eds.), Advances in animal welfare science (pp. 21-39). Washington: Humane Society of the United States.
  110. Zentall, T. R. (2004). Action imitation in birds. Learning & Behavior: A Psychonomic Society Publication, 32(1), 15-23., DOI: 10.3758/BF03196003
  111. Zimmerman, M. (1986). Physiological mechanisms of pain and its treatment. Klinische Anaesthesiol. Intensivtherapie, 32, 1-19.

Maria Elide Vanutelli, Michela Balconi, in "RICERCHE DI PSICOLOGIA " 2/2019, pp. 385-416, DOI:10.3280/RIP2019-002008


FrancoAngeli is a member of Publishers International Linking Association a not for profit orgasnization wich runs the CrossRef service, enabing links to and from online scholarly content