Clicca qui per scaricare

Il confronto tra cristiani e platonici nel II-III secolo
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Marco Zambon 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2015 Fascicolo: Lingua: Italiano 
Numero pagine:  16 P. 473-488 Dimensione file:  100 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2015-002010
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 


This article analyses the objections against Christianity made by Platonists of the II and III centuries and the way Christian intellectuals replied to these objections and used Platonic thought in the construction of their theology. Platonists considered Christianity a non-philosophical choice of life because of its irrationality. On their side, Christians defended the rationality of their faith and its superiority over Plato’s philosophy, which they considered to be rooted in Biblical revelation. The faith on which the adherence to Christianity is based is sometimes presented as a basic level of knowledge that everybody can attain and at others as a kind of knowledge superior to philosophy, though not in disaccord with it. Consequently, doctrines that are typical of the Platonic tradition are integrated into Christian theology and at the same time their meaning is radically changed.


Keywords: Middle Platonism, ancient Christianity, history of Christian theology, anti- Christian polemics, faith and reason

  1. - Beutler 1953: Rudolf Beutler, Porphyrios, in Paulys Real-Encyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft, XXII, Metzlersche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Stuttgart 1953, coll. 275-313.
  2. - Burnyeat 2005: Myles F. Burnyeat, Platonism in the Bible. Numenius of Apamea on Exodus and Eternity, in Metaphysics, Soul and Ethics in Ancient Thought, ed. by Ricardo Salles, Clarendon, Oxford 2005, pp. 143-169.
  3. - Chiossone 2005: Alessandro di Licopoli, Contro i Manichei, a cura di Francesco Chiossone, Il Melangolo, Genova 2005.
  4. - Dainese 2012: Davide Dainese, Passibilità divina. La dottrina dell’anima in Clemente Alessandrino, Citta Nuova, Roma 2012.
  5. - Danielou 1975: Jean Danielou, Messaggio evangelico e cultura ellenistica, Il Mulino, Bologna 1975 [ed. or. 1961].
  6. - de Vogel 1961: Cornelia de Vogel, «Ego sum qui sum» et sa signification pour une philosophie chrétienne, ≪Revue des sciences religieuses≫, XXXV (1961), pp. 337-355.
  7. - de Vogel 1985: Ead., Platonism and Christianity: a Mere Antagonism or a Profound Common Ground?, ≪Vigiliae Christianae≫, XXXIX (1985), pp. 1-62.
  8. - Dorrie 1976: Heinrich Dorrie, Une exégèse néoplatonicienne du prologue de l’évangile selon saint Jean. [Amélius chez Eusèbe, Prép. év. 11,19,1-4], in Id., Platonica minora, Fink, Munchen 1976, pp. 491-507.5. - Fabricius 1988: Cajus Fabricius, Zu den Aussagen der griechischen Kirchenväter über Platon, ≪Vigiliae Christianae≫, XLII (1988), pp. 179-187.
  9. - Fernandez Eyzaguirre 2006: Samuel Fernandez Eyzaguirre, ‘Passio Caritatis’ according to Origen “In Ezechielem Homiliae” VI in the Light of Dt 1, 31, ≪Vigiliae Christianae ≫, LX (2006), pp. 135-147.
  10. - Gavrilyuk 2004: Paul L. Gavrilyuk, The Suffering of the Impassible God. The Dialectics of Patristic Thought, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2004.
  11. - Gilson 1983: Etienne Gilson, Constantes philosophiques de l’être, ed. par Jean-Francois Courtine, Vrin, Paris 1983.
  12. - Goulet 2003: Macarios de Magnesie, Le monogénès, 2 vols., Introduction generale, edition critique, traduction francaise et commentaire par Richard Goulet, Vrin, Paris 2003.
  13. - Hadot 1978: Pierre Hadot, Dieu comme acte d’être dans le néoplatonisme. A propos des théories d’É. Gilson sur la métaphysique de l’Exode, in Dieu et l’être. Exégèses d’Exode 3, 14 et de Coran 20, 11-24, Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 1978, pp. 57-63.
  14. - Harl 1978: Marguerite Harl, Citations et commentaires d’Exode 3, 14 chez les Pères Grecs des quatre premiers siècles, in Dieu et l’être. Exégèses d’Exode 3, 14 et de Coran 20, 11-24, Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 1978, pp. 87-108.
  15. - von Harnack 1916: Porphyrius, «Gegen die Christen», 15 Bücher. Zeugnisse, Fragmente und Referate, hrsg. v. Adolf von Harnack, Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin 1916.
  16. - Hasenhutl 2008: Franz Hasenhutl, Die Heidenrede im “Octavius” des Minucius Felix als Brennpunkt antichristlicher Apologetik. Weltanschauliche und gesellschaftliche Widersprüche zwischen paganer Bildungsoberschicht und Christentum, LIT, Wien 2008.
  17. - Johnson 2010: Aaron P. Johnson, Rethinking the Authenticity of Contra Christianos fr. 1, in Studia Patristica, XLVI, Peeters, Leuven-Paris-Walpole (Ma) 2010, pp. 53-58.
  18. - Kobusch 1992: Theo Kobusch, Kann Gott leiden? Zu den philosophischen Grundlagen der Lehre von der Passibilität Gottes bei Origenes, ≪Vigiliae Christianae≫, XLVI (1992), pp. 328-333.
  19. - Lanata 1994: Celso, Il discorso vero, a cura di Giuliana Lanata, Milano, Adelphi, 1994 [1987].
  20. - Lettieri 1998: Gaetano Lettieri, Lo gnosticismo: la sua essenza e le sue origini, ≪Lateranum ≫, LXIV (1998), pp. 629-648.
  21. - Levieils 2007: Xavier Levieils, Contra Christianos. La critique sociale et religieuse du christianisme des origines au concile de Nicée (45-325), Walter de Gruyter, Berlin – New York 2007.
  22. - Lilla 1971: Salvatore Lilla, Clement of Alexandria. A Study in Christian Platonism and Gnosticism, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1971.
  23. - Lona 2005: Die Wahre Lehre des Kelsos, ubersetzt und erklart von Horacio E. Lona, Herder, Freiburg-Basel-Wien 2005.
  24. - Meijering 1974: Eginhard P. Meijering, Wie platonisierten Christen? Zur Grenzziehung zwischen Platonismus, kirchlichem Credo und patristischer Theologie, ≪Vigiliae Christianae≫, XXVIII (1974), pp. 15-28.
  25. - Morlet 2009: Sebastien Morlet, La Demonstration evangelique d’Eusèbe de Césarée. Étude sur l’apologétique chrétienne à l’époque de Constantin, Institut d’Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 2009.
  26. - Morlet 2011: Id., Le traité de Porphyre contre les chrétiens. Un siècle de recherches, nouvelles questions. Actes du Colloque international organisé les 8-9 septembre 2009 à l’Université Paris IV-Sorbonne, ed. par Sebastien Morlet, Institut d’Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 2011.
  27. - Nautin 1978: Pierre Nautin, «Je suis celui qui est» (Exode 3, 14) dans la théologie d’Origène, in Dieu et l’être. Exégèses d’Exode 3, 14 et de Coran 20, 11-24, Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 1978, pp. 109-119. - Prinzivalli 2002: Emanuela Prinzivalli, Magister Ecclesiae: il dibattito su Origene fra III e IV secolo, Istituto Patristico Augustinianum, Roma 2002.
  28. - Ridings 1995: Daniel Ridings, The Attic Moses. The Dependency Theme in Some Early Christian Writers, Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis, Goteborg 1995.
  29. - Rizzi 1999: Marco Rizzi, Il didaskalow nella tradizione alessandrina: da Clemente all’Oratio Panegyrica in Origenem, in Magister. Aspetti culturali e istituzionali. Atti del Convegno, Chieti, 13-14 novembre 1997, a cura di Giulio Firpo e Giuseppe Zecchini, Edizioni dell’Orso, Alessandria 1999, pp. 177-198.
  30. - Spanu 2012; Nicola Spanu, Plotinus, Ennead II 9 [33]. ‘Against the Gnostics’. A Commentary, Peeters, Leuven 2012.
  31. - Starobinski-Safran 1978: Esther Starobinski-Safran, Exode 3, 14 dans l’oeuvre de Philon d’Alexandrie, in Dieu et l’être. Exégèses d’Exode 3, 14 et de Coran 20, 11-24, Etudes Augustiniennes, Paris 1978, pp. 47-55.
  32. - van der Horst-Mansfeld 1974: Pieter W. van der Horst-Jaap Mansfeld, An Alexandrian Platonist against Dualism: Alexander of Lycopolis’ Treatise ‘Critique of the Doctrines of Manichaeus’. Translated with an Introduction and Notes, Brill, Leiden 1974.
  33. - Villey 1985: Alexandre de Lycopolis, Contre la doctrine de Mani, ed. par Andre Villey, Les Editions du Cerf, Paris 1985.
  34. - Wilamowitz 1900: Ulrich von Wilamowitz-Moellendorff, Ein Bruchstück aus der Schrift des Porphyrius gegen die Christen, ≪Zeitschrift fur die Neutestamentliche Wissenschaft ≫, I (1900), pp. 101-105.
  35. - Zambon 2003: Marco Zambon, Paranomos zen: la critica di Porfirio ad Origene (Eus. H.E. VI 19, 1-9), in Origeniana Octava. Origen and the Alexandrian Tradition. Origene e la tradizione alessandrina. Papers of the 8th International Origen Congress. Pisa, 27-31 August 2001, I, ed. by Lorenzo Perrone, Leuven University Press, Leuven 2003, pp. 553-563.
  36. - Zambon 2012: Id., Porphyre. Contra Christianos, in Dictionnaire des philosophes antiques, publie sous la direction de Richard Goulet, Vb, CNRS Editions, Paris 2012, pp. 1419-1447.

Marco Zambon, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 2/2015, pp. 473-488, DOI:10.3280/SF2015-002010

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche