Clicca qui per scaricare

L’errore deliberativo secondo Aristotele
Titolo Rivista: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Autori/Curatori: Francesca Alesse 
Anno di pubblicazione:  2015 Fascicolo: Lingua: Italiano 
Numero pagine:  22 P. 695-716 Dimensione file:  578 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2015-004001
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più:  clicca qui   qui 


The article aims to investigate Aristotle’s view on the types of errors occurring in practical reasoning or ‘deliberation’. The Author’s survey clarifies the difference between error in deliberation and moral error, considers to what extent deliberation corresponds to the so-called ‘practical syllogism’, and lastly recognizes three types of errors related to either perception or opinion. In the second case, the error in deliberation may correspond to a wrong opinion in general (without implying a nefarious intent) or to an incorrect assessment of the circumstances.


Keywords: Aristotle, deliberation, choice, practical syllogism, circumstances

  1. - Natali 1989: Carlo Natali, La saggezza di Aristotele, Bibliopolis, Napoli 1989.
  2. - Natali 2010: Carlo Natali, Particular Virtues in the Nicomachean Ethics of Aristotle, in R.W. Sharples (ed.), Particulars in Greek Philosophy. The seventh S.V. Keeling Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy, Brill, Leiden-Boston 2010, pp. 73-96.
  3. - Natali 20107: Aristotele. Etica nicomachea, traduzione, introduzione e note a cura di C. Natali, Roma-Bari, Laterza, 20107.
  4. - Nielsen 2011: Karen M. Nielsen, Deliberation as Inquiry: Aristotle’s Alternative to the Presumption of Open Alternatives, «Philosophical Review», CXX (2011), pp. 383-421. - Nussbaum 1978: Martha C. Nussbaum (ed.), Aristotle’s De motu animalium. Text with Translation, Commentary and Interpretative Essays, Princeton 1978.
  5. - Peterson 1988: Sandra Peterson, Horos (Limit) in Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, «Phronesis», XXXIII (1988), pp. 233-250.
  6. - Reeve 1998: C.D.C Reeve, Dialectic and Philosophy in Aristotle, in Jyl Gentzler (ed.), Method in Ancient Philosophy, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1998, pp. 227-252.
  7. - Corcilius 2008: K. Corcilius, Praktische Syllogismen bei Aristoteles, «Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie», XC (2008), pp. 247-97.
  8. - Abizadeh 2002: Arash Abizadeh, The Passions of the Wise: “Phronêsis”, Rhetoric, and Aristotle’s Passionate Practical Deliberation, «The Review of Metaphysics», LVI (2002), pp. 267-296.
  9. - Reeve 2014: Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics. Translated with Introduction and Notes by C.D.C. Reeve, Hackett Publ. Company, Indianapolis 2014.
  10. - Allan 1955: Donald J. Allan, The Practical Syllogism, in Autour d’Aristote. Recueil d’études de philosohie ancienne et médiévale offert à Monseigneur A. Mansion, Publications Universitaires de Louvain, Louvain 1955, pp. 325-340
  11. - Aronadio 2013: Francesco Aronadio, Le azioni compiute sotto costrizione, le azioni “miste” e la nozione di volontarietà (Eth. nic. G 1), «Elenchos», XXXIV (2013), pp. 155-187.
  12. - Aubenque 1963: Pierre Aubenque, La prudence chez Aristote, PUF, Paris 1963.
  13. - Bäck 2009: Allan Bäck, Mistakes of Reason: Practical Reasoning and the Fallacy of Accident, «Phronesis», LIV (2009), pp. 101-135.
  14. - Rese 2003: Friederike Rese, Praxis und Logos bei Aristoteles. Handlung, Vernunft und Rede in «Nikomachischer Ethik», «Rhetorik» und «Politik», Mohr, Tübingen 2003.
  15. - Balle 2010: Johannes D. Balle, Proa¤resiw. Zum Einheit von Mittel und Zweck in Aristoteles’ Teorie praktischen Razionalität, «Archiv für Begriffsgeschichte», LII (2010), pp. 34-51.
  16. - Barnes 19932: Jonathan Barnes (ed.), Aristotle. Posterior Analytics, Oxford, 19932.
  17. - Berti 2008: Enrico Berti, Ragione pratica e normatività in Aristotele, in E. Berti, Nuovi studi aristotelici, III: Filosofia pratica, Morcelliana, Brescia 2008, pp. 25-38.
  18. - Berti 2009: Enrico Berti, “Phainomena” ed “endoxa” in Aristotele, in Walter Lapini-Luciano Malusa-Letterio Mauro (a c. di), Gli Antichi e noi. Scritti in onore di Antonio Mario Battegazzore, Brigati, Genova 2009, vol. I, pp. 107-119.
  19. - Broadie 1991: Sarah Broadie, Ethics with Aristotle, OUP, New York-Oxford 1991.
  20. - Burnyeat 1980: Myles F. Burnyeat, Aristotle on Learning to Be Good, in Amélie Oksenberg Rorty (ed.), Essays on Aristotle’s Ethics, University of California Press, Berkeley-Los Angeles 1980, pp. 93-102.
  21. - Sauvé Meyer 20112: Susan Sauvé Meyer, Aristotle on Moral Responsibility. Character and Cause, OUP, Oxford 20112.
  22. - Segvic 2011: Heda Segvic, Deliberation and Choice in Aristotle, in Michael Pakaluk-Giles Pearson (eds.), Moral Psychology and Human Action in Aristotle, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2011, pp. 159-185.
  23. - Sherman 1985: Nancy Sherman, Character, Planning, and Choice in Aristotle, «The Review of Metaphysics», XXXIX (1985), pp. 83-106.
  24. - Timmermann 2008: Jens Timmermann, Syllogismen der praktischen Unvernunft?, in Klaus Corcilius-Cristof Rapp (Hrsg.), Beiträge zur Aristotelischen Handlungstheorie. Akten der 8. Tagung der Karl und Getrud Abel-Stiftung vom 08.-11.07.2006 in Blankensee, Steiner, Stuttgart 2008, pp. 131-41.
  25. - Wiggins 1980: David Wiggins, Deliberation and Practical Reason, in Amélie Oksenberg Rorty (ed.), Essays on Aristotle’s Ethics, University of California Press, Berkeley-Los Angeles 1980, pp. 221-240
  26. - Zingano 2013: Marco Zingano, Moral Particularism and Aristotelian Ethics, in Gabriela Rossi (ed.), Nature and the Best Life. Exploring the Natural Bases of Practical Normativity in Ancient Philosophy, Olms, Hildesheim-Zürich-New York 2013, pp. 95-123.
  27. - Cattanei 2008: Elisabetta Cattanei, Aristotele e i “calcoli” dell’uomo saggio, in M. Migliori-A. Fermani (ed.), Platone e Aristotele. Dialettica e Logica, Morcelliana, Brescia 2008, pp. 61-86.
  28. - Charles 1984: David Charles, Aristotle’s Philosophy of Action, Baylis & Son, London 1984.
  29. - Charles 2010: David Charles, Definition and Explanation in the Posterior Analytics and Metaphysics, in D. Charles (ed.), Definition in Greek Philosophy, Oxford 2010, repr. 2013, pp. 287-328.
  30. - Cooper 1975: John M. Cooper, Reason and Human Good in Aristotle, Cambridge (Mass.)-London 1975.
  31. - Cooper 2013: John M. Cooper, Aristotelian Responsibility, «Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy», XLV (2013), pp. 265-312.
  32. - Crubellier 2004: Michel Crubellier, Le «syllogisme pratique» ou comment la pensée meut le corps, in A. Laks-M. Rashed (éds), Aristote et le mouvement des animaux. Dix études sur le De motu animalium, Septentrion, Lille 2004, pp. 9-26.
  33. - Devereux 1986: Daniel T. Devereux, Particular and Universal in Aristotle’s Conception of Practical Knowledge, «Review of Metaphysics», XXXIX (1986), pp. 484-504.
  34. - Donini 1989: Pierluigi Donini, Ethos. Aristotele e il determinismo, Edizioni Dell’Orso, Alessandria 1989
  35. - Donini 20052: Aristotele. Etica eudemia, traduzione, introduzione e note a cura di Pierluigi Donini, Roma-Bari, Laterza, 20052. - Donini 2014: Pierluigi Donini, Abitudine e saggezza. Aristotele dall’Etica eudemia all’Etica nicomachea, Edizioni dell’Orso, Alessandria 2014.
  36. - Fait 1998: Paolo Fait, Endoxa e consenso. Per la distinzione dei due concetti in Aristotele, «Annali dell’Istituto Italiano per gli Studi Storici», XV (1998), pp. 15-48.
  37. - Garzaniti 2007: Justine Garzaniti, Vrai, faux, persuasion et vraisemblance. Dialectique et rhétorique chez Aristote, «Revue Philosophique de Louvain», CV (2007), pp. 311-332.
  38. - Gastaldi 2014: Aristotele. Retorica. Introduzione, traduzione e commento di Silvia Gastaldi, Carocci, Roma 2014.
  39. - Gauthier-Jolif 19702: René Antoine Gauthier-Jean Yves Jolif (éds.), Aristote. L’Éthique à Nicomaque. Introduction, traduction et commentaire, Louvain-Paris, 19702.
  40. - Gourinat 2004: Jean-Baptiste Gourinat, Syllogisme pratique et logique déontique, in André Laks-Marwan Rashed (éds), Aristote et le mouvement des animaux. Dix études sur le De motu animalium, Septentrion, Lille 2004, pp. 27-66,
  41. - Hardie 19802: William Francis R. Hardie, Aristotle’s Ethical Theory, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 19802
  42. - Hitz 2012: Zena Hitz, Aristotle on Law and Moral Education, «Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy», XLII (2012), pp. 264-306.
  43. - Kenny 1979: Anthony Kenny, Aristotle’s Theory of the Will, Duckworth, London 1979.
  44. - Klein 1988: Sherwin Klein, An Analysis and Defense of Aristotle’s Method in Nicomachean Ethics I and X, «Ancient Philosophy», VIII (1988) pp. 63-73.
  45. - Kraut 1998: Richard Kraut, Aristotle on Method and Moral Education, in Jyl Gentzel (ed.), Method in Ancient Philosophy, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1998, pp. 271-290.
  46. - Leszl 1991: Walter Leszl, Alcune specificità del sapere pratico in Aristotele, in Antonina Alberti (a c. di), Studi sull’etica di Aristotele, Bibliopolis, Napoli 1991, pp. 99-111.
  47. - Leunissen 2010: Mariska Leunissen, Explanation and Teleology in Aristotle’s Science of Nature, Cambridge 2010, repr. 2011.
  48. - Lorenz 2009: Hendrik Lorenz, Virtue of Character in Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, «Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy», XXXVII (2009), pp. 177-212.
  49. - Mele 1981a: Alfred R. Mele, The Practical Syllogism and Deliberation in Aristotle’s Causal Theory of Action, «The New Scholasticism», LV, 1981, pp. 281-316.
  50. - Mele 1981b: Alfred R. Mele, Choice and Virtue in the Nicomachean Ethics, «Journal of the History of Philosophy», XIX (1981), pp. 405-423.
  51. - Mignucci 1965: Mario Mignucci, La teoria aristotelica della scienza, Sansoni, Firenze 1965.
  52. - Miller 1984: F. D. Miller, Aristotle on Rationality in Action, «The Review of Metaphysics », XXXVII, 1984, pp. 499-520.
  53. - Moss 2011: Jessica Moss, “Virtue Makes the Good Right”: Virtue and Phronesis in Aristotle’s Ethics, «Phronesis», LVI, 2011, pp. 204-261.

Francesca Alesse, in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 4/2015, pp. 695-716, DOI:10.3280/SF2015-004001

   

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association associazione indipendente e no profit per facilitare l'accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche