Click here to download

The correspondence between Leibniz and Fontenelle: the contribution from the unpublished manuscripts.
Journal Title: RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA 
Author/s: Rita Fanari 
Year:  2015 Issue: Language: Italian 
Pages:  25 Pg. 743-767 FullText PDF:  575 KB
DOI:  10.3280/SF2015-004003
(DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation:  clicca qui   and here 


This article deals with the importance of the epistolary exchange between Leibniz and Fontenelle. Our knowledge of their correspondence is still incomplete, but Fontenelle’s critics emphasize the importance of his relationship with Leibniz. Despite no complete edition of the Leibniz-Fontenelle correspondence having yet been published, it is possible to consult the original manuscripts in Bodemann’s collection. The Ritter-Katalog includes four of Leibniz’s unpublished letters and different versions of an important letter written on 7 April 1703. The article deals with these unpublished manuscripts, in particular on two of them, which provide important information. The first, dated 6 January 1703 and never previously analyzed, reveals a fundamental engagement with metaphysical issues through focusing on the notion of substance, the laws of motion and related problems. The second, dated 7 April 1703 and in three different unpublished versions, continues his detailed and intense discussion of motion. The unpublished manuscripts show the difficulties faced by Leibniz in the draft texts and the importance he attached to Fontenelle’s opinion given that he sent him the texts on his metaphysics and dynamics.
Keywords: Leibniz, Fontenelle, correspondence, epistolary, manuscripts, metaphysics, dynamic

  1. - raccolta Bodemann, LBr 275, ff. 6, 6a-6b; 7; 14-15; 18-19; 20-21; LBr 68, ff. 41; 139-140.
  2. - Blay 1999: Michel Blay, Les infinis de Fontenelle, in Jeanne-Marie Lardic (Dir.), L’infini entre science et religion au XVIIe siècle, Vrin, Paris 1999, pp. 129-142.
  3. - Barber 1955: William Barber, Leibniz in France. From Arnauld to Voltaire, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1955. - Birembaut, Costabel, Delorme 1966: Arthur Birembaut, Pierre Costabel et Suzanne Delorme, La correspondance Leibniz-Fontenelle et les relations de Leibniz avec l’Académie royale des Sciences en 1700-1701, in «Revue d’histoire des sciences et des leurs applications», 1966, vol. 19, n. 19-2, pp. 115-132.
  4. - De Tommaso 2006: Emilio Maria De Tommaso, Controversie intellettuali: Leibniz e Bayle, 1686-1706, Rubbettino, Napoli 2006.
  5. - Duchesneau 1993: François Duchesneau, Leibniz et la méthode de la science, PUF, Paris 1993.
  6. - Duchesneau 1994: Id., La dynamique de Leibniz, Vrin, Paris 1994.
  7. - Fichant 1998: Michel Fichant, Science et métaphysique dans Descartes et Leibniz, PUF, Paris 1998.
  8. - Fontenelle 1991: Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle, OEuvres complètes, Fayard, Paris 1991, a cura di Alain Niderst.
  9. - Foucher de Careil 1854: Louis-Alexandre Foucher de Careil, Lettres et opuscules inédits de Leibniz, Librairie philosophique de Ladrange, Paris 1854.
  10. - Leibniz 1859: Gottfried Wilhlem Leibniz, Mathematische Schriften, hrsg. Carl Immanuel Gerhardt, Berlin 1859;
  11. - Leibniz 1982: Id., Specimen dynamicum, hrsg. von Hans G. Dosch-Glenn W. Most-Enno Rudolph, Meier, Hamburg 1982.
  12. - Leibniz 1994: Id., La réforme de la dynamique. De corporum concursu (1678) et d’autres textes inédits, par Michel Fichant, Vrin, Paris 1994.
  13. - Leibniz 2007: Id., Dialoghi filosofici e scientifici, a cura di Francesco Piro, Gianfranco Mormino ed Enrico Pasini, Bompiani, Milano 2007.
  14. - Lissa 1971: Giuseppe Lissa, Cartesianesimo e anticartesianesimo in Fontenelle, Libreria Scientifica, Napoli 1971.
  15. - Marcialis 1978: Maria Teresa Marcialis, Fontenelle. Un filosofo mondano, Gallizzi, Sassari, 1978.
  16. - Mormino 2011: Gianfranco Mormino, Leibniz entre Huygens et Newton: force centrifuge et relativité du mouvement dans les lettres de 1694, in IX. Internationaler Leibniz-Kongress unter der Schirmherrschaft des Bundespräsidenten. Natur und Subjekt, Hartmann, Hannover 2011, Teil 2, pp. 697-705.
  17. - Niderst 1972: Alain Niderst, Fontenelle à la recherche de lui-même, Nizet, Paris 1972.
  18. - Robinet 1986: André Robinet, Architectonique disjonctive, automates systémiques et idéalité transcendantale dans l’oeuvre de Leibniz, Vrin, Paris 1986.
  19. - Robinet 1989: Id., Fontenelle à la recherche de Leibniz, in Fontenelle. Actes du Colloque tenu à Rouen du 6 au 10 octobre 1987, PUF, Paris 1989.

Rita Fanari, The correspondence between Leibniz and Fontenelle: the contribution from the unpublished manuscripts. in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 4/2015, pp. 743-767, DOI:10.3280/SF2015-004003

   

FrancoAngeli is a member of Publishers International Linking Association a not for profit orgasnization wich runs the CrossRef service, enabing links to and from online scholarly content