A Universal Allowance to all Citizens: Juliet Rhys-Williams’ Alternative to The Beveridge Plan

Author/s Cosma Orsi
Publishing Year 2017 Issue 2017/1 Language English
Pages 32 P. 35-66 File size 283 KB
DOI 10.3280/SPE2017-001002
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Studying the social and economic ideas underpinning political debates offers a deeper understanding of policy decision-making and institutional change. According to a well-established tradition, policies "can be regarded as embodying ideas about society, the economy, the state, citizens and relations between these. They embody views about justice, equality and individual responsibility" (Alcock et. al. 2000: 184). With this in mind, we shall investigate Lady Juliet Rhys-Williams’ critical reflections on the Beveridge Report and the alternative proposal she presented in Something to Look Forward to (1943). In this book, she elaborated an integrated approach to social security and income tax aimed at providing "complete security to those classes, especially the independent workers, widows and spinsters, who are not adequately covered by the Beveridge scheme" (Rhys-Williams 1943: vii). At the very heart of her social vision was the idea of distributing a universal allowance (basic income system) to all British citizens (children included). The rationale underpinning Rhys-Williams’ basic income system was the recognition that the problem afflicting British society was the ill-distribution of wealth, that hindered economic growth and prevented the attainment of full employment.

Keywords: Rhys-Williams, Beveridge, Basic income system.

Jel codes: B20, B31

  1. Abbott E. and Bompas K. (1943). The Woman Citizen and Social Security, London, Women’s Freedom League.
  2. Alcock C. et al. (2000). Introducing Social Policy, London, Routledge.
  3. Atkinson A. B. (1995). Incomes and the Welfare State. Cambridge, University Press, Cambridge.
  4. Atkinson A. B. and Weale M. (2000). James Edward Meade. 1907-1995. Proceedings of the British Academy, 105, London, The British Academy: 473-500.
  5. Bellamy R. P. (1992). Liberalism and Modern Society: A Historical Argument, PA, Pennsylvania State University Press.
  6. Benassi D. (2010). Father of the Welfare State? Beveridge and the Emergence of the Welfare State, Sociologica, 3: 1-15.
  7. Beveridge W. (1905). Plan for The Unemployed: An Economic Question, The Beveridge Papers, Reel 2, Section 3, Item 12.
  8. Beveridge W. (1907). The Problem of the Unemployed, Sociological Papers, III, London, Macmillan: 323-331.
  9. Beveridge W. (1909). Unemployment: A Problem of Industry, London. Longmans, Green & Co.
  10. Beveridge W. (1942). Social Insurance and Allied Services. Report by Sir William Beveridge. London: HMSO.
  11. Beveridge W. (1945a [1944]). Full Employment in a Free Society, London, George Allen & Unwin.
  12. Beveridge W. (1945b). Why I am a Liberal, London, H. Jenkins Ltd.
  13. Beveridge W. (1949 [1948]). Voluntary Action: A Report on Methods of Social Advance, London, Allen & Unwin Ltd.
  14. Bowley A. L. (1920). Changes in the Distribution of National Incomes 1883-1913. In A. L.
  15. Bowley (ed.) (1938), Three Studies on the National Income, London, London School of Economics.
  16. Bowley A. L. and Stamp, J. C. (1924). The National Income. In A. L. Bowley (ed.) (1938). Three Studies on the National Income. London, London School of Economics.
  17. Cairncross A. (1993). James Meade. In A.B. Atkinson (ed.) Alternatives to Capitalism: The Economics of Partnership, London, Macmillan: 1-5.
  18. Chiozza-Money L. G. (1905). Riches and Poverty, London, Methuen.
  19. Cole G. D. H. (1929). The Next Ten Year in British Social and Economic Policy, London, Garland.
  20. Cole G. D. H. (1935). Principles of Economic Planning, London, Macmillan & Co.
  21. Cutler T. et al. (1986). Keynes, Beveridge and Beyond, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
  22. D’Aeth F. G. (1910). Present Tendencies of Class Differentiation, Sociological Review, 3, (4): 267-76.
  23. Daunton M. (2002). Just Taxes. The Politics of Taxation in Britain 1914-1979; Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  24. Dimand R. W. (1999). The Beveridge Retort: Beveridge’s Response to the Keynesian Challenge. In L. L. Pasinetti and B. Schefold (eds.) The Impact of Keynes on Economics in the 20th Century, Cheltenham UK and Northampton USA, Edward Elgar: 221-240.
  25. Dorrance G. and Leeson, R. (1997). Obituary: James Edward Meade, CB FBA, Murdoch University, Working Paper, 161.
  26. Douglas C. H. (1920). Economic Democracy, London, Cecil Palmer.
  27. Douglas C. H. (1922). Credit, Power and Democracy, London, Cecil Palmer.
  28. Douglas P. H. (1924). The British Discussion of Family Endowment, The Journal of Social Forces, 3, (1): 118-124.
  29. Esping-Andersen G. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
  30. Ferrera M. (1993). Modelli di solidarietà, Il Mulino, Bologna.
  31. Ferrera M. (1996). The ́Southern` Model of Welfare State in Social Europe, Journal of European Social Policy, 6, (1): 17-37.
  32. Friedman M, (1962), Capitalism and Freedom, Chicago, Chicago University Press.
  33. Freeden M. (1986). Liberalism Divided A Study in British Political Thought, 1914-1939. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  34. Great Britain Ministry of Reconstruction (1944). Social Insurance, Par t I, Cmd. 6550 H. M. Stationery Office, London,
  35. Hansen H.(1938). Full Recovery or Stagnation? New York, W. W. Norton.
  36. Hansen H. (1939). Economic Progress and Declining Population Growth. The American Economic Review, 1 (1): 1-15.
  37. Haynes A. T. and Kirton R. J. (1946 [1943]). Income Tax in Relation to Social Security. Journal of the Institute of Actuaries, 72 (1):79-118.
  38. Harris N. (1973). Competition and the Corporate Society. British Conservatives, the State and Industry 1945-1964, London and New York, Routledge.
  39. Harris J. (1977). William Beveridge: A Biography, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
  40. Harris J. (1981). Some Aspects of Social Policy in Britain During the Second World War. In W. J. Mommsen (ed.), The Emergence of the Welfare State in Britain Germany 1850-1950, London, Croom Helm.
  41. Harris J. (1994). Beveridge’s Social and Political Thought. In J. Hills et al (eds.), Beveridge and Social Security, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 26-42.
  42. Harris J. (1999). Social Policy, Savings, and Sound Money: Budgeting for the New Jerusalem in the Second World War. In P. Clarke and C. Trebilock (eds.) Understanding Decline: Perception and Realities of British Economic Performance, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 166-85
  43. HobsonJ. (1910). Industrial System. An Inquiry into Earned and Unearned Income; London, Longmans Green & Co.
  44. Johnson E. and Moggridge D. (eds.) (1980). The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes. Activities 1940-1946: Shaping the Post-war World: Employment and Commodities, 27, London, Macmillan.
  45. Keynes J. M. (1973 [1936]). The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money. London: The Royal Economic Society.
  46. Keynes J. M. (1937). Some Economic Consequences of a Declining Population. Eugenics Review, 29 (1): 13-17
  47. Keynes J. M. (1938). Review of J. E. Meade, Consumers’ Credits and Unemployment. The Economic Journal, 48 (189): 67-71.
  48. Komine A. (2010). Beveridge on Welfare Society: An Integration of the Trilogy. In R. E. Backhouse and T. Nishizawa (eds.) No Wealth but Life. Welfare Economics and the Welfare State in Britain 1880-1945, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 207-221.
  49. Lampman R. (1965). Approaches to the Reduction of Poverty, American Economic Review, 55: 521–29.
  50. Layard R. and Weale M. (1995) Obituary: James Meade, The Independent, 29 December – on line source accessed 29 February 2017.
  51. Liberal Party (1944). Family Allowance and Social Security: Lady Rhys Williams’ Scheme, with the Report of a Liberal Committee Thereon, London, Liberal Publication Department.
  52. Liberal Party (1944). The Government’s Employment Policy Examined: An Interim Report of the Liberal Party Committee on Full Employment, London, Liberal Publication Department.
  53. Liberal Party (1950). Reform of Income Tax and Social Security Payments: A Liberal Party Yellow Book, London, Liberal Publication Department and the Scottish Liberal Party.
  54. Lange O. (1936-7). On the Economic Theory of Socialism, Review of Economic Studies, 4: Pt. I 1936: 53-71; Pt. II 1937: 123-42
  55. Llewellyn Smith H. (1932). The New Survey of London Life and Labour, Survey of Social Conditions: The Eastern Area, London, P. S. King.
  56. Llewellyn Smith H. (1934). The New Survey of London Life and Labour, Survey of Social Conditions: The Western Area, London, P. S. King.
  57. Mair-Beveridge P. (1982). Shared Enthusiasm: The Story of Lord and Lady Beveridge, London, Ascent Book.
  58. Macnicol J. (2002). The Politics of Retirement in Britain 1878-1948, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  59. Marshall A. (1980). Principles of Economics, London, Macmillan.
  60. McKay A. (2005). The Future of Social Security Policy: Women, Work, and Citizens’ Basic Income, London, Routledge.
  61. Meade J. E. (1988 [1935]). Outline of Economic Policy for the Labour Government. In S. Howson, and D. Muggeridge (eds.) The Collected Papers of James Meade, I, London, Unwin Hyman.
  62. Meade J. E. (1936). An Introduction to Economic Analysis, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  63. Meade J. E. (1938). Consumer Credits and Unemployment. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  64. Meade J. E. (1948). Planning and the Price Mechanism: The Liberal-Socialist Solution, London, George Allen & Unwin.
  65. Milner D. and Milner M. (1918). Scheme for a State Bonus, London, Kent & Company.
  66. Milner D. (1920) Higher Production by a Bonus on National Output. A Proposal for a Minimum Income for All Varying With National Income, London, George Allen & Unwin.
  67. Moggridge D. (1992). Maynard Keynes. An Economic Biography, London & New York, Roudledge.
  68. Nicoll W. (2008 [2004]). ‘Williams, Dame Juliet Evangeline Rhys (1898-1964)’. In Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford, Oxford University Press - online edition accessed 30 March 2017.
  69. Parker E. (1989). Instead of the Dole: An Enquiry into Integration of the Tax and Benefit System, London, Routledge.
  70. Peacock A. T. (1952). The Economics of National Insurance, London, William Hodge.
  71. Peacock A. T. (2010). Anxious to do Good. Learning to be an Economist the Hard Way. Essex, Imprint Academic.
  72. Pickard B. (1918). A Reasonable Revolution: Being a Discussion of the State Bonus Scheme - a Proposal for a National Minimum Income, London, George Allen & Unwin.
  73. Pierson C. and Castles F. G. (eds.) (2006). The Welfare State. A Reader, Cambridge, Polity Press. Report of the Official Committee on the Beveridge Report, 1943, PRO, PIN 8/85.
  74. Rhys-Williams J. (1942). Some Suggestions for a new Social Contract: an Alternative to the Beveridge Report proposals, s. n.
  75. Rhys-Williams J. (1943). Something to Look Forward to. A Suggestion for a New Social Contract, London, MacDonald. Rhys-Williams J. 1944. Notes on the White Paper on Full Employment, Rhys-Williams Paper J/2/8/1.
  76. Rhys-Williams J. and Thorneycroft P. (1947). Design for Survival, London, Design for Freedom.
  77. Rhys-Williams J. (1953). Taxation and Incentives, London, William Hodge.
  78. Romer J. (1991). Market Socialism, a Blueprint: How Such an Economy May Work. In F. Roosevelt and D. Belkin, Why Market Socialism? Voices from Dissent, New York and London, M. E. Sharpe.
  79. Robinson J. (1937). Essays in the Theory of Employment, London, Macmillan.
  80. Robinson J. (1937a), Introduction to the Theory of Unemployment, London, Macmillan. Rowntree, B. S. 1943. Poverty and the Beveridge Plan, The Fortnightly, 73-80.
  81. Russell B. (1919 [1918]). Proposed Roads to Freedom, Socialism, Anarchism and Syndicalism, New York, H. Holt.
  82. Shragge E. (1984). Pension in Britain: A Socialist Analysis, London, Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  83. Sloman P. (2015). The Liberal Party and the Economy, 1929-1964, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
  84. Sloman P. (2016). Beveridge’s Rival: Juliet Rhys-Williams and the Campaign for Basic Income, 1942-55, Contemporary British History, 30 (2): 203-223.
  85. The Times (1964). ‘Juliet Lady Rhys-Williams’, 19 September
  86. Theobald R. (1965 [1963]). Free Man and Free Market, New York, DoubleDay Anchor Book.
  87. Titmuss R. (1963 [1958]).War and Social Policy. In R. Titmuss (ed.) Richard Titmuss’ Essays on the Welfare State, London, Allen & Unwin, 75-87.
  88. Timmins R. (1995). The Five Giants: A Biography of the Welfare State, London, Harper Collins.
  89. Torry M. (2012). The United Kingdom: Only for Children? In R. K. Caputo (ed.) Basic income Guarantee and Politics: International Experiences and Perspectives on the Viability of Income Guarantee, New York, Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 253-63.
  90. Veit-Wilson J. H. (1992). Muddle or Mendacity: the Beveridge Committee and the Poverty Line, Journal of Social Policy, 21, 3: 269-301.
  91. Walter T. (1989). Basic Income. Freedom from Poverty, Freedom from Work, London & New York, Marion Boyars.
  92. Webb S. and Webb B. (1897). Industrial Democracy, London, Longmans Green.
  93. Wedgwood J. (1929). The Economics of Inheritance, Harmondsworth, Penguin.
  94. Wilson E. (1977). Women and the Welfare State, London, Tavistock.
  95. Van Trier, W. (1989). Every One a King, Leuven, Catholic University of Leuven.
  96. Van Trier W. (2002). Who Framed Social Dividend? Paper presented to the USBIG Conference, CUNY, New York on line source accessed 30 March 2017.

Cosma Orsi, A Universal Allowance to all Citizens: Juliet Rhys-Williams’ Alternative to The Beveridge Plan in "HISTORY OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT AND POLICY" 1/2017, pp 35-66, DOI: 10.3280/SPE2017-001002