The Jews, a neurasthenic people: a cultural construction of European psychiatry between the nineteenth and twentieth centuries

Journal title ITALIA CONTEMPORANEA
Author/s Vinzia Fiorino
Publishing Year 2018 Issue 2018/286 Language Italian
Pages 29 P. 209-237 File size 0 KB
DOI 10.3280/ic286-oa1
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

View article Download Open Access article

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Since the second half of the 19th century, the idea that Jews were particularly subject to specific nervous pathologies, especially neurasthenia, has been the object of a wide-ranging debate among the most authoritative European psychiatrists. The idea that "A neurasthenic trait passes over the whole race" might represent a conclusive and significant phase in this vast international controversy. This normative code was conceptualized primarily by Charcot and in his school. Included in the epistemic framework of hysterical neurosis, such an interpretation explained that the ancient image of the wandering Jew, with an uncertain gait and a flaccid body, far from being the result of a divine curse, was the outcome of a racial predisposition aggravated by the practice of consanguineous marriages. The debate became more intense, it became a mere statistical fact, it created some resistance and perplexity, but was strongly acquired by many Jewish intellectuals who, however, attenuated its most negative consequences. This article reconstructs the dissemination and variations of this important normative code, which was re-proposed for many decades: during the Fascist era, for example, an important paradigmatic change left the code virtually undetected, while at the same time repeating it in an increasingly schematic way. In different contexts, the code marked a strangeness of the Jewish people vis-à-vis the purity of the body of the Nation, placing itself at the centre of important dilemmas concerning the model of modern civilization, aesthetic canons, and gender roles.

Keywords: Anti-semitism, Jewish Neuroses, History of Psychiatry, Wandering Jew

  1. Luigi Benevelli, (2010), La psichiatria coloniale italiana negli anni dell’Impero (1936-1941), Lecce, Argo.
  2. Riccardo Bonavita, (2009), Spettri dell’altro. Letteratura e razzismo nell’Italia contemporanea, in Giuliana Benvenuti e Michele Nani (a cura di), Bologna, Il Mulino.
  3. Nicole Edelman, (2005), Pathologisation du juif et antisémitisme à la Salpêtrière à la fin du XIXe siècle, in Marie-Anne Matard-Bonucci (a cura di), Antisémythes. L’image des juifs entre culture et politique (1848-1939), Paris, Nouveau monde éditions, collection Culture/Médias, pp. 81-93.
  4. John M. Efron, (2001), Medicine and the German Jews. A History, New Haven-London, Yale University Press.
  5. Francesco Germinario, (2011), Argomenti per lo sterminio. L’antisemitismo e i suoi stereotipi nella cultura europea (1850-1920), Torino, Einaudi.
  6. Aaron Gillette, (2002), Racial theories in fascist Italy, London-New York, Routledge.
  7. Sander Gilman, (1991), The Jew’s Body, New York, Routledge.
  8. Ann Goldberg, (1996), The Limits of Medicalization: Jewish Lunatics and Nineteenth-Century Germany, “History of Psychiatry”, 7, pp. 265-285.
  9. Jan Goldstein, (2013), Isteria complicata da estasi: lo strano caso di Nanette Leroux. Pisa, ETS.
  10. Jan Goldstein, (1985), The Wandering Jew and the Problem of Psychiatric Anti-semitism in Fin-de-Siècle France, “Journal of Contemporary History”, vol. 20, n. 1, pp. 521-551.
  11. George L. Mosse, (1982), Il razzismo in Europa. Dalle origini all’Olocausto, Roma-Bari, Laterza.
  12. George L. Mosse, (1997), L'immagine dell'uomo. Lo stereotipo maschile nell'epoca moderna, Torino, Einaudi.
  13. Todd S. Presner, (2007), Muscolar Judaism. The Jewish Body and the Politics of Regeneration, London and New York, Routledge.

  • Science and pseudo science: racist eugenics in Italy Carlo Patriarca, Piergiorgio Modena, Maura Massimino, Fabio Gibilisco, Mattia Barbareschi, Andreas Conca, in Pathologica 5/2023 pp.117
    DOI: 10.32074/1591-951X-844

Vinzia Fiorino, Gli ebrei, un popolo di nevrastenici: una costruzione culturale della psichiatria europea tra Otto e Novecento in "ITALIA CONTEMPORANEA" 286/2018, pp 209-237, DOI: 10.3280/ic286-oa1