Machines of Nature and Machines of Art: Christian Wolff’s Reception of Leibniz

Journal title RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA
Author/s Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero
Publishing Year 2019 Issue 2019/3 Language English
Pages 22 P. 431-452 File size 80 KB
DOI 10.3280/SF2019-003002
DOI is like a bar code for intellectual property: to have more infomation click here

Below, you can see the article first page

If you want to buy this article in PDF format, you can do it, following the instructions to buy download credits

Article preview

FrancoAngeli is member of Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA), a not-for-profit association which run the CrossRef service enabling links to and from online scholarly content.

Christian Wolff’s failed attempt to appropriate Leibniz’s distinction between machines of nature and machines of art is significant from both a historical and a theoretical point of view. After considering Wolff’s early distinction between nature and art in terms of an active principle or force (Section 1), this paper reconstructs the sudden re-appearance of Leibniz’s concept of natural machine in Wolff’s 1724 Anmerckungen (Section 2). Sections 3-4 analyze Wolff’s definitions of the general concept of machine in terms of structures and functions respectively, and argue that Leibniz’s doctrine of natural machines only makes sense against the background of the functional account. Thus, Wolff’s attempt to appropriate Leibniz’s idea brings to light its fundamentally teleological inspiration (Section 5). However, Wolff departs from Leibniz in that he refrains from characterizing natural machines as those whose parts are themselves natural machines ad infinitum. As a consequence, Wolff’s organic bodies are not indestructible like Leibniz’s ones, and the boundary between the realms of nature and art is blurred (Section 6).

Keywords: Artefacts, mechanism, structure, function, teleology

  1. - Baumgarten 1739: Alexander Gottlieb Baumgarten, Metaphysica, Hemmerde, Halle 1739.
  2. - Bilfinger 1723: Georg Bernhard Bilfinger, De harmonia animi et corporis humani, maxime præstabilita, ex mente illustris Leibnitii, commentatio hypothetica, Mezler, Frankfurt-Leipzig 1723 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1984).
  3. - Bilfinger 1725: Id., Dilucidationes philosophicae de Deo, anima humana, mundo, et generalibus rerum affectionibus, Cotta, Tübingen 1725 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1982).
  4. - Canz 1750: Israel Gottlieb Canz, Meditationes philosophiae, Cotta, Tübingen 1750 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1996).
  5. - Carboncini 1995: Sonia Carboncini, Alle origini della filosofia tedesca: Crisi della metafisica dogmatica e fondazione della libertà, in Robert Theis, Claude Weber (dir.), De Christian Wolff à Louis Lavelle. Métaphysique et histoire de la philosophie, Olms, Hildesheim, 1995, pp. 16-33.
  6. - Descartes 1964-1974: René Descartes, OEuvres, éd. Charles Adam, Paul Tannery, 11 vols., Vrin-CNRS, Paris 1964-1974.
  7. - Favaretti Camposampiero 2009: Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, Conoscenza simbolica. Pensiero e linguaggio in Christian Wolff e nella prima età moderna, Olms, Hildesheim [etc.] 2009.
  8. - Favaretti Camposampiero 2011: Id., What Follows from the Contingency of Natural Laws? Christian Wolff’s Reaction to a Leibnizian Argument, in Herbert Breger et al. (Hrsg.), IX. Internationaler Leibniz-Kongress. Natur und Subjekt, Hartmann, Hannover 2011, pp. 341-350.
  9. - Favaretti Camposampiero 2012: Id., Leggi di natura e mondi possibili: Leibniz, Wolff e Bilfinger, «Verifiche», 41, 2012, pp. 361-386.
  10. - Favaretti Camposampiero 2016a: Id., Bodies of Inference: Christian Wolff’s Epistemology of the Life Sciences and Medicine, «Perspectives on Science», XXIV (2016), pp. 361-379.
  11. - Favaretti Camposampiero 2016b: Id., Christian Wolff’s Philosophy of Medicine: An Early Functional Analysis of Health and Disease, «Quaestio», XVI (2016), pp. 75-94.
  12. - Favaretti Camposampiero forthcoming: Id., Infinite Regress: Wolff’s Cosmology and the Background of Kant’s Antinomies, «Kant-Studien», forthcoming.
  13. - Fichant 2003: Michel Fichant, Leibniz et les machines de la nature, «Studia Leibnitiana», XXXV (2003), pp. 1-28.
  14. - Fischer 1975: Klaus P. Fischer, John Locke in the German Enlightenment: An Interpretation, «Journal of the History of Ideas», XXXVI (1975), pp. 431-446.
  15. - Goclenius 1615: Rodolphus Goclenius, Lexicon philosophicum græcum, Musculus, Marchioburgi 1615.
  16. - Grmek 1990: Mirko Draˇzen Grmek, La première révolution biologique. Réflexions sur la physiologie et la médecine du XVIIe siècle, Payot, Paris 1990.
  17. - Hanov 1766: Michael Christoph Hanov, Philosophiæ naturalis sive physic dogmaticæ tomus III continens geologiam, biologiam, phytologiam generalem et dendrologiam, Renger, Halæ 1766 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1997).
  18. - Lamarra 2001: Antonio Lamarra, Le traduzioni settecentesche della Monadologie. Christian Wolff e la prima ricezione di Leibniz, in A. Lamarra et al. (a cura di), Le prime traduzioni della Monadologie di Leibniz (1720-1721), Olschki, Firenze 2001, pp. 1-117.
  19. - Leibniz 1875-1890: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Die philosophischen Schriften, hrsg. von Carl Immanuel Gerhardt, 7 vols., Weidemann, Berlin 1875-1890 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1960).
  20. - Leibniz 1923: Id., Sämtliche Schriften und Briefe, Akademie Verlag, Berlin 1923ff.
  21. - Leibniz 1989: Id., Philosophical Papers and Letters, trans. Leroy E. Loemker, 2nd ed., Kluwer, Dordrecht 1989.
  22. - Leibniz, Clarke 2000: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Samuel Clarke, Correspondence, ed. Roger Ariew, Hackett, Indianapolis-Cambridge 2000.
  23. - Leibniz, Wolff 1860: Briefwechsel zwischen Leibniz und Christian Wolff, hrsg. Von Carl Immanuel Gerhardt, Schmidt, Halle 1860 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1963).
  24. - Locke 1975: John Locke, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, ed. Peter H. Nidditch, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1975.
  25. - Mayr 1986: Otto Mayr, Authority, Liberty and Automatic Machinery in Early Modern Europe, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore-London 1986.
  26. - McLaughlin 2002: Peter McLaughlin, Naming Biology, «Journal of the History of Biology», XXXV (2002), pp. 1-4.
  27. - Meissner 1737: Heinrich Adam Meissner, Philosophisches Lexicon aus Christian Wolffens sämmtlichen teutschen Schrifften, Vierling, Bayreuth-Hof 1737.
  28. - Mühlpfordt 1989: Günter Mühlpfordt, Die organischen Naturwissenschaften in Wolffs empiriorationalistischer Enzyklopädistik, «Il cannocchiale», II-III (1989), pp. 77–106.
  29. - Nachtomy 2011: Ohad Nachtomy, Leibniz on Artificial and Natural Machines: Or What It Means to Remain a Machine to the Least of Its Parts, in Justin Erik Halldór Smith, Ohad Nachtomy (eds.), Machines of Nature and Corporeal Substances in Leibniz, Springer, Dordrecht [etc.] 2011, pp. 61-80.
  30. - Neumann 2010: Hanns-Peter Neumann, Machina machinarum. Die Uhr als Begriff und Metapher zwischen 1450 und 1750, «Early Science and Medicine», XV (2010), pp. 122-191.
  31. - Perrault 1680-1688: Claude Perrault, Essais de physique, ou recueil de plusieurs traitez touchant les choses naturelles, tomes I-IV, Coignard, Paris 1680-1688.
  32. - Perrault, Perrault 1721: Claude Perrault, Pierre Perrault, OEuvres diverses de physique et de mécanique, volumes I-II, Pierre van der Aa, Leide 1721.
  33. - Pimpinella 2005: Pietro Pimpinella, Machina come immagine del mondo in Christian Wolff, in Marco Veneziani (a cura di), Machina. Atti dell’XI Colloquio Internazionale del Lessico Intellettuale Europeo, Olschki, Firenze 2005, pp. 421-446.
  34. - Rutherford 1992: Donald P. Rutherford, Leibniz’s Principle of Intelligibility, «History of Philosophy Quarterly», IX (1992), pp. 35-49.
  35. - Shaw 1725: Peter Shaw, The Philosophical Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle, volumes I-III, Innys [etc.], London 1725.
  36. - Schulthess 1999: Daniel Schulthess, Machines finies et machines infinies chez Leibniz, in Dominique Berlioz, Frédéric Nef (éds.), L’actualité de Leibniz: les deux labyrinthes, Stuttgart, Steiner 1999, pp. 633-642.
  37. - Wolff 1703: Christian Wolff, Disquisitio philosophica de loquela, Göz, Lipsae 1703 (repr. in Wolff 1755, Sect. II, pp. 244-267).
  38. - Wolff 1710: Id., Anfangs-Gründe der Mechanick oder Bewegungs-Kunst, in Der Anfangs-Gründe aller mathematischen Wiessenschaften anderer Theil, Renger, Halle 1710 (repr. of the 1757 ed.: Olms, Hildesheim 1973).
  39. - Wolff 1713: Id., Elementa mechaniae et statiae, in Elementa matheseos univerae. Tomus I, Renger, Haae 1713 (repr. of the 1733 ed.: Olms, Hildesheim 1968).
  40. - Wolff 1716: Id., Mathematisches Lexicon, Gleditsch, Leipzig 1716 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1965).
  41. - Wolff 1718: Id., Ratio praelectionum Wolfianarum in mathesin et philosophiam universam, Renger, Halle 1718 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1972).
  42. - Wolff 1720: Id., Vernünfftige Gedancken von Gott, der Welt und der Seele des Menschen, auch allen Dingen überhaupt [= Deutsche Metaphysik], Renger, Halle 1720 (ed. Charles A. Corr, Olms, Hildesheim 1983).
  43. - Wolff 1721: Id., [Review of] Recueil de diverses pièces sur la philosophie etc. [...]. Tomi II. Amstelodami, apud Du Villardum et Changuionium, 1720, «Acta Eruditorum», February (1721), pp. 88-94 (repr. in Id., Sämtliche Rezensionen in den Acta Eruditorum (1705-1731), hrsg. von Hubert A. Laeven, Lucy J.M. Laeven-Aretz, vol. 3, Olms, Hildesheim 2001).
  44. - Wolff 1723: Id., Vernünfftige Gedancken von den Würckungen der Natur, Renger, Halle 1723 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1981).
  45. - Wolff 1724a: Id., Anmerckungen über die vernünfftigen Gedancken von Gott, der Welt und Seele des Menschen, auch allen Dingen überhaupt, Andreä, Franckfurt 1724 (ed. Charles A. Corr, Olms, Hildesheim 1983).
  46. - Wolff 1724b: Id., Vernünfftige Gedancken von den Absichten der natürlichen Dinge, Renger, Halle 1724 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1980).
  47. - Wolff 1725: Id., Vernünfftige Gedancken von dem Gebrauche der Theile in Menschen, Thieren und Pflantzen, Renger, Franckfurt-Leipzig 1725 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1980).
  48. - Wolff 1728: Id., Philosophia rationalis sive logica, methodo scientifica pertractata, 3 vols., Renger, Francofurti-Lipsae 1728 (hrsg. von Jean École, Olms, Hildesheim 1983).
  49. - Wolff 1730a: Id., De notione sanitatis, in Hoae subseciae marburgenses anni 1729. Trimestreaestivum, Renger, Francofurti-Lipsae 1730 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1983), pp. 318-355.
  50. - Wolff 1730b: Id., Philosophia prima, sive Ontologia, methodo scientifica pertractata, Renger, Francofurti-Lipsae 1730 (hrsg. von Jean École, Olms, Hildesheim 1962)
  51. - Wolff 1731: Id., Cosmologia generalis, methodo scientifica pertractata, Renger, Francofurti-Lipsae 1731 (hrsg. von Jean École, Olms, Hildesheim 1964).
  52. - Wolff 1734: Id., Psychologia rationalis methodo scientifica pertractata, Renger, Francofurti-Lipsae 1734 (hrsg. von Jean École, Olms, Hildesheim 1994).
  53. - Wolff 1750: Id., Kurtzer Unterricht von den vornehmsten mathematischen Schriften. Neue, verbesserte und vermehrte Auflage, Renger, Franckfurt-Leipzig 1750 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1973).
  54. - Wolff 1755: Id., Meletemata mathematico-philosophica, Renger, Haae 1755 (repr. Olms, Hildesheim 1974).
  55. - Zedler 1739: Johann Heinrich Zedler (Hrsg.), Grosses Universal-Lexicon aller Wissenschafften und Künste, vol. 19, Zedler, Halle-Leipzig 1739.

  • Immortal animals, subtle bodies, or separated souls: the afterlife in Leibniz, Wolff, and their followers Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, in Intellectual History Review /2023 pp.651
    DOI: 10.1080/17496977.2022.2116199
  • Vegetative Powers Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, pp.419 (ISBN:978-3-030-69708-2)
  • Mechanism, Life and Mind in Modern Natural Philosophy Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, pp.279 (ISBN:978-3-031-07035-8)
  • Galen and the Early Moderns Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, pp.155 (ISBN:978-3-030-86307-4)

Matteo Favaretti Camposampiero, Machines of Nature and Machines of Art: Christian Wolff’s Reception of Leibniz in "RIVISTA DI STORIA DELLA FILOSOFIA" 3/2019, pp 431-452, DOI: 10.3280/SF2019-003002